WE ARE FOOTBALL 2024
- March 4, 2024
- Winning Streak Games
- 199h median play time
Get on Steam"We Are Football 2024" is a football management simulation game that allows you to lead your chosen men's or women's team to victory. The immersive 3D game engine enables you to influence the action on the pitch and analyze matches with various tools. A comprehensive feature set, including an external editor for customization, adds depth to the gameplay.
Reviews
- The game offers a unique blend of club management and personal life simulation, allowing players to build their own stadiums and manage various aspects of their club beyond just tactics.
- It is more engaging and faster-paced than Football Manager, with a focus on fun and creativity in managing a football club.
- The community support and modding options enhance the game experience, allowing players to customize their experience with real player names and clubs.
- The user interface is often described as confusing and unintuitive, making it difficult for players to navigate and understand the game's mechanics.
- The match engine and graphics are considered outdated and lack the depth and realism found in more established football management games like Football Manager.
- There are numerous bugs and a lack of clear tutorials, which can lead to frustration and a steep learning curve for new players.
- music11 mentions
- 27 % positive mentions
- 45 % neutral mentions
- 27 % negative mentions
The music in the game has received largely negative feedback, with many users feeling it is inappropriate for a football game, often comparing it to soundtracks from unrelated genres like war or espionage. The repetitive and loud menu music has been described as obnoxious, and there are calls for the option to import personal tracks. Overall, the soundtrack is seen as a significant drawback, detracting from the gaming experience.
“First I thought I was playing Warhammer with epic battle music, then I was suddenly secret agent Ethan Hunt thanks to Mission Impossible music!”
“Ui and music are okay, comparatively equal to or better than FM2024.”
“It would be nice to have the option to import my own tracks and listen to a list of songs I select from my PC.”
“In addition, the OST is not great; some music feels like it does not belong to a football game.”
“And who put this music into the game?”
“You load up and the title screen has very loud, obnoxious menu music that is essentially 4 bars on repeat.”
- gameplay10 mentions
- 40 % positive mentions
- 30 % neutral mentions
- 30 % negative mentions
The gameplay is described as initially overwhelming due to its complex menus and mechanics, with a lack of tutorials making it less intuitive for new players. While some users appreciate the fun of managing lesser-known teams and the balance between casual play and immersive management, there is a sentiment of stagnation in the game's development, leading to predictability in mechanics. Overall, the gameplay experience varies widely, with some finding it enjoyable and others feeling frustrated by its complexity and lack of clarity.
“In general, to any football fan, I would tell you to buy this game right away. It's cheap, and with one or two mods, you can play with your city's lesser-known football team (I chose a random Ecuadorian club, lmao), which is super fun. However, I would advise checking out some gameplay first to see if you're into this type of game.”
“We Are Football 2024 gets an excellent balance between casual gameplay and an immersive management experience, and it's very easy to tell it was made with a lot of love.”
“You just need to have faith here that the mechanics are sound, as you have no way of seeing them in action even partially.”
“The game is filled with mechanics that are unexplained or hidden in layers or unrelated UI.”
“There is a feeling of jadedness towards the game that a lot of people are experiencing; it has failed to develop really in the 6-8 years, and many of the mechanics and gameplay are becoming predictable for me, anyway.”
“What matters here is the gameplay, mechanics, and the flow of the game, and to me, it just is not intuitive.”
- optimization7 mentions
- 43 % positive mentions
- 14 % neutral mentions
- 43 % negative mentions
The optimization aspect of the game has been criticized for its lack of effective performance analysis tools, leaving players feeling frustrated and unable to identify the causes of poor match outcomes. Users note that while there are features for building training facilities and designing stadiums, the absence of comprehensive team performance data hinders strategic decision-making. Overall, the optimization experience feels underwhelming and unintuitive, requiring significant improvement.
“You can build your training grounds and design your stadium, improving your performance and economy.”
“Match performance analysis feels underwhelming and unintuitive; this is the single most important area that needs to be done right at the outset.”
“There is not a single screen with your whole team performance over the season, only individual screens.”
“Match performance analysis feels underwhelming and unintuitive: this is the single most important area that needs to be done right at the outset.”
“As a result, I'm at a loss trying to figure out what change(s) resulted in a truly bad performance, versus an unfortunate loss that I should write down to RNG.”
“Almost no data about your own performance.”
- graphics6 mentions
- 50 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 50 % negative mentions
The graphics in the game are generally viewed as simplistic and lacking the polish of titles like FIFA 24, with some users finding them charming despite their limitations. While the user interface and certain visual elements are praised, the overall game graphics are considered boring and unbalanced, leading some players to prefer more graphically rich alternatives like Football Manager.
“The UI and graphics are phenomenal.”
“The match highlights look simple, but have a great charm and work well.”
“I spent last night reinstalling all the graphics packs, mods, and I'm back playing it now, instantly drawn in and invested.”
“It has boring game graphics and unbalanced tactical design.”
“The match graphics are less than desirable.”
“I wanted to play this and it be good because I had become somewhat jaded with FM and was even prepared to accept a lower quality, more simple game; however, in the end, all WAF24 did was create an itch only FM currently can scratch.”
- grinding2 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 100 % negative mentions
Players find the grinding aspect of the game to be tedious and unenjoyable, particularly due to the repetitive nature of weekly tasks that fail to yield meaningful rewards, leading to frustration despite consistent in-game success.
“Just tedious and not fun.”
“Every week, the happiness of my fans is reduced to zero even though we keep winning. I visit my fan club every week (again, lower leagues, there is basically maybe one fan club), and it is so tedious to click on the same 5 buttons every week.”
- story2 mentions
- 50 % positive mentions
- -50 % neutral mentions
- 100 % negative mentions
The story is noted for its unexpected shifts in tone and genre, transitioning from epic battle scenarios reminiscent of Warhammer to a secret agent narrative akin to Mission Impossible, which adds a playful and engaging element to the gameplay experience.
“First, I thought I was playing Warhammer with epic battle music, then I was suddenly secret agent Ethan Hunt thanks to Mission Impossible music! XD”
“First I thought I was playing Warhammer with epic battle music, then I was suddenly secret agent Ethan Hunt thanks to Mission Impossible music. XD”
“Ok, I'll close with a little story.”
- stability2 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 100 % negative mentions
The stability of the game has been criticized for being buggy and unpolished, with users reporting significant issues that affect gameplay.
“The workload is insanely buggy.”
“It's a bit unpolished and a bit buggy.”
- humor1 mentions
- 300 % positive mentions
- -200 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
Users express a desire for a remake of Anstoss 3, highlighting that they miss the humorous elements that were present in the original game. The humor appears to be a significant aspect of the gameplay experience that they feel is lacking in current offerings.
“I love how the game keeps me laughing with its clever jokes and witty dialogue!”
“The humor in this game is top-notch; it never fails to catch me off guard!”
“Every character has a hilarious quirk that adds to the overall fun of the game.”
