Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun is a game that hits me right square in the nostalgia, almost completely disarming of my faculties as a critic. As a love letter to the fans of Commandos, it is a dream come true.
Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun is a tactical stealth game that transports players to Japan during the Edo period. As a player, you lead a team of deadly specialists, each with their own unique abilities, on a series of missions to prevent civil war. Sneak, ambush, and fight your way through levels filled with patrolling enemies, obstacles, and puzzles, utilizing the team's skills to outsmart and overcome your foes. Immerse yourself in this beautifully designed world with stunning visuals and evocative music.
The game offers high replayability with diverse mission structures and multiple approaches to objectives, appealing especially to completionists.
The graphics are stunning, capturing the essence of feudal Japan with beautiful environments and detailed character designs, complemented by an exceptional soundtrack.
The gameplay features deep tactical mechanics and engaging stealth elements, allowing for strategic planning and experimentation, which many players find rewarding.
Some players feel that the replay value diminishes after completing all challenges, particularly for those not focused on achievement hunting.
The character development is seen as lacking depth, with some players desiring more elaborate interactions and growth throughout the story.
There are reports of performance issues and bugs, particularly with controls and pathfinding, which can detract from the overall experience.
story
4,920 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
35%
62%
3%
The story of "Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun" is generally well-received, with many players appreciating its engaging narrative set in feudal Japan. While some find the plot predictable and cliché, the character development and interactions throughout the missions add depth and emotional weight, making players feel invested in their fates. The game combines a compelling storyline with tactical gameplay, allowing for multiple approaches to mission objectives, which enhances replayability and keeps the experience fresh.
“This game has probably the most impactful story moment I've ever seen in a video game.”
“Enjoyable characters and quite an interesting storyline with a few surprising twists.”
“Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun is a masterpiece of a game that combines engaging gameplay, captivating storytelling, and breathtaking visuals to create an immersive experience that is both challenging and rewarding.”
“The plot is pretty standard fare, with very predictable plot twists.”
“The story is simple but fit the game style.”
“The story is quite predictable and uses many common Japanese archetypes.”
gameplay
2,532 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
48%
49%
3%
The gameplay of "Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun" is widely praised for its deep tactical mechanics, engaging stealth elements, and the ability to control multiple characters with unique abilities. Players appreciate the game's challenging nature, which encourages strategic planning and experimentation, often requiring trial and error to succeed. While some critiques mention a lack of polish and occasional frustrations with controls, the overall consensus highlights the game's rewarding gameplay loop, beautiful art style, and compelling character interactions, making it a standout title for fans of the tactical stealth genre.
“It has great characters, a good art style, good music, and such great in-depth tactical gameplay.”
“The gameplay is a perfect mix of stealth and strategy.”
“The gameplay is sound, definitely nice to play.”
“The gameplay is a bit rough around the edges and the team did improve with subsequent games, for example pausing while using tactics mode or a fast forward button.”
“The gameplay could have been a tiny bit more polished but I understand it was a dress rehearsal before unleashing the hors d'oeuvre (aka Desperados 3).”
“The gameplay is quite repetitive and the controls seem to have been designed to actively hinder the player.”
graphics
1,237 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
63%
36%
1%
The graphics of "Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun" have received widespread praise for their beautiful, semi-stylized art style that effectively captures the essence of feudal Japan. Many reviewers noted the game's vibrant colors, detailed environments, and character designs, which contribute to an immersive experience, although some mentioned that the graphics can feel somewhat dated compared to newer titles. Overall, the visuals are considered a strong point of the game, enhancing both the gameplay and storytelling.
“The graphics are stunning, with beautifully rendered environments and detailed character models.”
“The graphics are beautiful and the voice acting - both in Japanese and English - is great.”
“Nothing new and the graphics look old.”
“The game's visuals, particularly character animations, show signs of aging.”
“The graphics are innovative and diverse at times but are overall not crisp and too low-poly compared to what I expected from the screenshots.”
music
676 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
65%
34%
1%
The music in the game has received widespread acclaim for its ability to enhance the overall atmosphere, effectively capturing the essence of the Edo period in Japan. Reviewers praised the soundtrack for its beautiful compositions, blending traditional Japanese instruments with modern elements, creating an immersive experience that complements the gameplay and visuals. While some noted occasional repetitiveness, the majority found the music to be a standout feature, contributing significantly to the game's emotional depth and engagement.
“The soundtrack is simply amazing!”
“The music and visuals go right along with it.”
“The art style is really attractive, the voice acting is top notch, and the soundtrack is phenomenal - the combination really transports you to the game's world.”
“Most of the music in this game was okay, nothing special except for a few of them, but in the end, none of them got annoying and repetitive while playing.”
“The music is a little annoying at times as it seems to not loop clearly, or be just overall fairly bad.”
“The soundtrack is okay; it didn't have a strong appeal to my ears.”
replayability
460 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
38%
53%
9%
The game offers high replayability due to its diverse mission structures, allowing players to approach objectives in multiple ways and complete various challenges, such as earning badges for specific tasks. While many players appreciate the depth and variety of strategies available, some feel that the replay value diminishes after completing all challenges, particularly for those not focused on achievement hunting. Overall, it is well-regarded for its engaging gameplay and the potential for numerous playthroughs, especially for completionists.
“There are plenty of ways and tactics to be employed to complete each scenario, which adds to the game's replayability.”
“Each mission can be completed in a thousand different ways, and the internal medal system also adds to the replay value.”
“The game has a great replayability, offering three levels of difficulty for each level and numerous badges to be completed, each with a specific task that make the level harder or more interesting, forcing the player to try and solve each level with a new set of rules.”
“The developers added them to artificially increase the length of the game, and to force replayability.”
“My general complaint is lack of replayability (I am on the last mission, I think. But I also thought that to be the case 3 missions ago too...).”
“Characters have no customization or progression throughout the campaign, so hardly any replay value.”
atmosphere
233 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
72%
27%
1%
The atmosphere of the game is widely praised for its captivating and immersive qualities, effectively capturing the essence of the Edo period in Japan through stunning visuals, detailed environments, and an exceptional soundtrack. Players appreciate the attention to detail in the art style, character interactions, and atmospheric sound design, which collectively enhance the overall experience. The inclusion of optional Japanese voice acting further enriches the authenticity and enjoyment of the game's setting.
“The game has great, semi-stylized graphics and an awesome soundtrack and sound design, making for an altogether perfect Japanese atmosphere, aided by the (optional) Japanese voice-over.”
“The atmosphere, characters, and gameplay are all top notch.”
“The soundtrack acts as a stunning minstrel of the visuals, following it everywhere, composing fitting tunes that amplify the atmosphere and take the presentation to greater heights.”
“The only really positive things I have to say about this game are the atmospheres and aesthetics.”
“Most stealth games consider saving constantly (aka save scumming) to be a detriment to the experiment they are trying to craft because it cuts people from the atmosphere and the tension.”
“The story in this game is average, but the atmosphere and the feelings you get towards the characters more than makes up for that.”
grinding
122 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
2%
9%
89%
The reviews highlight a pervasive sense of tedium associated with grinding in the game, with many players expressing frustration over repetitive trial-and-error gameplay, lengthy levels, and the need for constant quicksaving and loading. While some appreciate the challenge and complexity, the overall sentiment leans towards the experience being overly tedious, particularly in later missions and when attempting to achieve all objectives. Despite its engaging elements, many players found the grinding aspect to detract significantly from their enjoyment.
“I'm playing through blind, with no reference to guides or walkthroughs, but it reloads really fast after death/failure, so quicksaves make sure it's not tedious.”
“Multiple types of enemies, guard formations and positioning, cover mechanics, optional hazards, and multiple abilities per character will make sure each level feels unique and no grinding or repetition.”
“It's not too easy, not too tedious.”
“The level was so tightly patrolled that it felt like a very tedious, trial and error slog of slowly peeling back an onion to do anything.”
“The worst part is that not only is it infuriatingly boring and ragingly tedious, it also forces you into these 'funnels' where there is no way through the guards unless you knock everyone out or kill them.”
“This game is so tedious that I can't find much enjoyment from it.”
optimization
107 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
41%
49%
10%
Overall, the game's optimization is highly praised, with many users reporting smooth performance, solid frame rates, and minimal crashes or bugs. Players appreciate the quick save/load feature that enhances gameplay flow, and the game runs well even on lower-end hardware. However, some users noted occasional performance issues, particularly related to specific scenes or hardware configurations, suggesting that further optimization could enhance the experience.
“The game is highly optimized in its quick save/load, so risky tactics and failures do not cost much in time to reload and don't take the player off the flow.”
“Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun is a well-polished game that has been optimized for PC, and can be played using both keyboard and mouse as well as a controller.”
“The gameplay is smooth and the game feels very well optimized.”
“Seems to have a memory leak or something that causes severely degraded performance after playing for a while.”
“I wish it was a bit more optimized; it struggled a little on my 960m 2GB card (1080p medium settings) despite not looking like an overly demanding game.”
“It suffers from terrible performance issues on all hardware.”
emotional
91 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
99%
1%
The emotional aspect of the game is highly praised, with many players expressing deep investment in the characters and story, often leading to poignant moments that evoke strong feelings, including sadness and joy. Reviewers highlight the captivating narrative, character development, and the ability to create a heartfelt connection, making the gameplay experience both engaging and memorable. Overall, the game is recognized for its effective emotional storytelling, which resonates with players long after completion.
“The story is emotionally engaging, and the characters feel real (to the point that I got annoyed with some of them like I would real people lol).”
“Love this game and the story even made me cry a little.”
“The incredibly fun gameplay apart, it ends up being a beautiful and emotional journey.”
stability
88 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
24%
3%
73%
Overall, the game's stability is a mixed bag; while many players report smooth performance and minimal bugs, others experience frustrating glitches, particularly with controls and pathfinding. Some users noted occasional crashes and freezing, especially on certain platforms like Linux and macOS, but many found workarounds or did not encounter significant issues. Despite these inconsistencies, the game is generally considered well-optimized and enjoyable, with a solid gameplay experience.
“It looks great, it runs great, and its gameplay is fluent, swift, and smooth. Very polished game from a developer who understands the topic and made this game with heart.”
“First off, the mechanics are near flawless -- characters are super responsive, hotkeys are easy and simple to remember, there aren't any 'slippery detection windows', and almost no glitches as far as I've found (at least, none that break the experience).”
“It's relatively bug free - I managed to run into one throughout the whole playthrough - and that's a real rarity nowadays.”
“The gameplay is great, but it's buggy, so much so I can't actually complete the game due to the game freezing in the final level.”
“The camera and mouse-control system are sometimes extremely irritating where the game demands on-the-fly UI interactions to ensure the missions go as planned; where the game doesn't allow you to queue multiple actions for each character and the UI frequently glitches and causes you to command a character to perform an entirely useless and acontextual action because the mouse intersects something else from its janky camera viewpoint.”
“Moving forwards on the list, the game also has a plethora of glitches with maps and character interactions that just decrease the fun factor of the game.”
humor
67 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The humor in the game is widely praised for its cleverness and charm, with players enjoying the witty dialogue, funny character interactions, and amusing gameplay moments. Many highlight the blend of humor with serious themes, creating a rich narrative experience that keeps players engaged. The game's quirky characters and their comedic antics, along with unexpected glitches, contribute to a lighthearted atmosphere that enhances the overall enjoyment.
“When you pull off some stupid, elaborate trick that borders on cheese, it's equal parts funny and satisfying.”
“I felt less smart leading 200 guards with a tanuki on a wild goose chase until they walked right into a very poorly hidden bear trap, but it never stopped being funny.”
“The dialogue is short but snappy; my favorite is the thief character: a young girl who earnestly believes she is setting the things she steals 'free' and it's hilarious.”
character development
65 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
49%
46%
5%
Character development in the game is a mixed bag, with some players praising the distinct personalities and skills of the characters, as well as their meaningful interactions and growth throughout the story. However, others feel that the development lacks depth and could benefit from more elaborate cutscenes or dialogue to enhance emotional investment. Overall, while character design is often highlighted as a strong point, the depth of character development varies, with some finding it superb and others deeming it simplistic.
“The character development is superb and is a highlight of the game.”
“The characters all have their own unique personalities and experience logical character development as the game unfolds.”
“Very touching story and amazing character development and a fitting end to the story.”
“I admit I didn't play it long, but I didn't see any kind of skills, level-building, or character development.”
“Almost like Baldur's Gate II but with stealth-based play and less to no character development.”
“The characters all have different relationships with each other, but there isn't enough 'screen time' for any real meaningful interaction or true character development.”
monetization
12 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
25%
8%
67%
Overall, the monetization aspect of the game is highly praised, with players appreciating the absence of microtransactions, loot boxes, and other cash grab tactics. The game is seen as a refreshing departure from mainstream titles that often rely on exploitative monetization strategies, although a minor in-game advertising feature is noted as a slight drawback. Players commend the developers for delivering a complete product without additional costs, enhancing the game's value.
“I also want to point out that these guys put out an original product bug-free, with full controller support, a generously sized demo, no microtransactions, and actually listen to their customers.”
“And if all of that hasn't convinced you, the soundtrack is great, the graphics are pretty, there are lots of cool achievements to collect, and there are no scummy microtransactions or paid DLCs besides the soundtrack (which you should totally buy).”
“There's no microtransactions!!!!”
“But all these great genres and games reached their peak and are a lot more mainstream that nowadays are repetitive and filled with BS microtransactions and other bad stuff.”
“Although this doesn't impact the gameplay directly, it can be seen as intrusive in-game advertising, which may not appeal to some players.”
“While the presence of in-game advertising is a minor downside, it doesn't overshadow the game's overall excellence.”