Sea of Thieves

+12

Skip Games Like Sea of Thieves

Looking for games like Sea of Thieves? Here are top open world simulation recommendations with a fantasy focus, selected from player-similarity data — start with Forgotten Seas, Terror of the Seven Seas or Salt.

79%355reviews

Forgotten Seas

2025

Open World Simulation

81%81reviews

Terror of the Seven Seas

2024

Open World Role Playing

76%1.7kreviews

Salt

2018

Open World Role Playing

Sea of Thieves

Action

87%31.6kreviews

Assassin's Creed IV Black Flag

2013

Open World Role Playing

+14

80%161.5kreviews

Sea of Thieves

2020

Open World Shooter

+6

Salt 2: Shores of Gold

Action

85%2kreviews

Blazing Sails

2020

Open World Shooter

93%967reviews

Swords 'n Magic and Stuff

2020

Open World Role Playing

80%669reviews

Kayak VR: Mirage

2022

Casual Racing

+6

More games like Sea of Thieves

Skip User Reviews

Reviews

gameplay5 positive mentions

story3 negative mentions

Incredible visuals and water simulation create a stunning and immersive experience.
Fun multiplayer gameplay encourages teamwork and interaction with other players.
The game has a unique charm and potential for emergent storytelling in a pirate-themed world.

Lacks meaningful content and variety, often relying on repetitive fetch quests.
Progression feels shallow and unsatisfying, with limited rewards beyond cosmetics.
Combat systems are poorly designed, leading to frustration in both PvE and PvP encounters.

gameplay
9 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
56% positive mentions, 11% neutral mentions, 33% negative mentions
The gameplay of Sea of Thieves has evolved significantly, offering a mix of engaging sailing mechanics, cooperative play, and a variety of activities that enhance the overall experience. While some players find the core gameplay loop repetitive and lacking depth, the introduction of new systems and features has added layers of strategy and excitement, particularly in player-versus-player interactions and exploration. Overall, the game successfully captures the pirate fantasy, providing a visually stunning world that is best enjoyed with friends.
- “Rare has spent two years building on the game's strong foundation with features, tools, and systems that improve the core gameplay. The newly added emissary system is a brilliant solution that incentivizes various play styles in smart ways. Ships of every size feel great to control, whether you're coordinating a galleon with three friends or soloing a sloop. Unlike at launch, there are now countless things to do, whether you want to fight other players, engage with 'tall tale' story missions, hunt skeleton fleets, or have any number of other adventures. The tension created by the possibility of being attacked at any moment has been enhanced by various new systems.”
- “Sea of Thieves' excellent gameplay loop and compelling world make up for some minor issues.”
- “It's a delight to steadily come to grips with the mechanics of the game too, whether that be how to outmaneuver enemy ships or sell your loot with quickened efficiency.”
- “There just isn't enough content or depth here; its core gameplay is grinding repetitive fetch quests and not a whole lot else. The progression here just isn't fulfilling, and the fun factor depends on who you're playing with.”
- “Desolate open-world; a lot more shallow than it appears. Where are all the sea monsters?! Achingly repetitive gameplay loop.”
- “The gameplay loop quickly becomes monotonous, lacking variety and depth, making it hard to stay engaged for long periods.”
story
7 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
29% positive mentions, 28% neutral mentions, 43% negative mentions
The story aspect of "Sea of Thieves" showcases a vibrant world with potential for emergent storytelling, yet many players feel it lacks depth and variety, leading to repetitive gameplay centered around fetch quests. While recent updates have introduced new features and missions, the overall narrative experience remains limited, leaving some players unfulfilled and questioning the game's long-term engagement.
- “The most beautiful video game sea you’ll ever see, emergent storytelling at its greatest.”
- “Rare has spent two years building on the game's strong foundation with features, tools, and systems that improve the core gameplay. The newly added emissary system is a brilliant solution that incentivizes various play styles in smart ways. Ships of every size feel great to control, whether you're coordinating a galleon with three friends or soloing a sloop. Unlike at launch, there are now countless things to do, whether you want to fight other players, engage with 'tall tale' story missions, hunt skeleton fleets, or have any number of other adventures. The tension created by the possibility of being attacked at any moment has been enhanced by various new systems.”
- “Sea of Thieves is bursting with potential for storytelling in a watery paradise, but doesn’t have enough to keep players coming back.”
- “There just isn't enough content or depth here; its core gameplay is grinding repetitive fetch quests and not a whole lot else. The progression here just isn't fulfilling, and the fun factor depends on who you're playing with.”
- “There is no quest variety, not much to see or do, and no reason to keep playing.”
graphics
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100% positive mentions, 0% neutral mentions, 0% negative mentions
The graphics of the game are widely praised for their fantastic visuals, superb animation, and unique charm, creating an amazing playground for players. However, some users feel that the world lacks content and features, leading to a sense of emptiness despite the beautiful aesthetics.
- “Amazing playground, superb visuals and animation.”
- “Beautiful visuals, great teamwork.”
- “While the graphics are fantastic and the game has a unique charm, ultimately the world feels empty, devoid of content and features.”
humor
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100% positive mentions, 0% neutral mentions, 0% negative mentions
The humor in "Sea of Thieves" continues to shine, providing players with hilariously fun high-seas adventures that are best enjoyed with friends. The recent PlayStation 5 port has expanded the player base, enhancing the comedic experience for even more participants.
- “Even after six years, Sea of Thieves remains a great time with friends, and now, with the PlayStation 5 port, even more friends can join in the hilariously fun high-seas adventures.”
- “The humor in this game is top-notch, with witty dialogue and hilarious situations that keep you laughing throughout your journey.”
- “Every encounter in the game is filled with unexpected comedic moments that make even the most intense battles feel light-hearted and fun.”
stability
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
0% positive mentions, 0% neutral mentions, 100% negative mentions
The game's stability has been criticized due to a buggy launch and inadequate social controls, leading to a less than polished experience for players.
- “The game launched with half-baked social controls and numerous bugs.”
- “Stability issues plagued the experience from the very beginning.”
- “Frequent crashes and glitches made it nearly unplayable at times.”
grinding
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
0% positive mentions, 0% neutral mentions, 100% negative mentions
Players find the grinding aspect of the game to be repetitive and unfulfilling, primarily revolving around monotonous fetch quests with limited content and depth. The enjoyment of the grinding experience seems to heavily rely on the social aspect of playing with others.
- “There just isn't enough content or depth here; its core gameplay is grinding repetitive fetch quests and not a whole lot else. The progression here just isn't fulfilling, and the fun factor depends on who you're playing with.”
- “The grinding feels endless and tedious, making it hard to stay engaged with the game.”
- “I found myself doing the same tasks over and over again, which made the experience feel more like a chore than a game.”
atmosphere
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100% positive mentions, 0% neutral mentions, 0% negative mentions
The atmosphere of the game is characterized as enjoyable, particularly when played with friends, and is enhanced by impressive water effects that contribute to a fun and engaging mood.
- “Fitfully enjoyable with three friends.”
- “Best-of-class water effects.”
- “Fun atmosphere and mood.”