Skip to main content

Puzzle Agent

88%Game Brain Score
story, graphics
replayability, stability
88% User Score Based on 4,036 reviews

Platforms

PCPCiPhoneiPhonePlaystation 3Playstation 3WindowsWindowsPlayStationPlayStationMac OSMac OSMobile PlatformMobile PlatformWiiWiiiPadiPadPhonePhone

About

Nelson Tethers, from the U.S. Department of Puzzle Research, is sent to investigate the Scoggins Eraser Company when they respond to White House inquiries with puzzles. The small town of Scoggins is full of brainteasers, riddles, and cryptograms that Tethers must solve to uncover the town's secrets and the core mystery. With its unique narrative and visual style, Puzzle Agent offers a thrilling and engaging experience for those who love puzzles.

Puzzle Agent screenshot
Puzzle Agent screenshot
Puzzle Agent screenshot
Puzzle Agent screenshot
Puzzle Agent screenshot
Puzzle Agent screenshot
Puzzle Agent screenshot
Puzzle Agent screenshot
Puzzle Agent screenshot
Puzzle Agent screenshot
Puzzle Agent screenshot
+18

88%
Audience ScoreBased on 4,036 reviews
story1.2k positive mentions
replayability28 negative mentions

  • Charming art style and engaging story that combines humor with eerie elements.
  • Variety of puzzles that range from easy to moderately challenging, providing a satisfying experience.
  • Great voice acting and well-written dialogue that enhances the overall atmosphere.
  • Some puzzles have vague or poorly explained instructions, leading to confusion.
  • The game is relatively short, taking only about 3-4 hours to complete, which may leave players wanting more.
  • The ending feels abrupt and unresolved, requiring players to purchase the sequel for closure.
  • story
    2,568 mentions Positive Neutral Negative

    The story of "Puzzle Agent" is a quirky and engaging narrative that blends elements of mystery, humor, and a touch of horror, reminiscent of shows like "Twin Peaks" and "Fargo." Players follow FBI agent Nelson Tethers as he investigates a bizarre case in a small town, solving a variety of puzzles that advance the plot. However, the story concludes on a cliffhanger, necessitating the purchase of the sequel for resolution, which has left some players feeling unsatisfied with the abrupt ending. Overall, while the story is entertaining and well-crafted, it is often criticized for its lack of closure and coherence.

    • “Like it's legitimately a great story that is perfectly balanced in tone.”
    • “You don't just solve puzzles; you unravel a story where each solution moves you deeper into a thickening plot filled with conspiracies and oddball characters.”
    • “Whether or not you're a puzzle enthusiast, the story itself is worth the journey, especially with its cinematic nods and cleverly scripted dialogue that often brings a chuckle.”
    • “❌ The game presents half of a story, and it concludes abruptly with a cliffhanger.”
    • “My biggest complaint is that the story doesn't answer all the mysteries at the end.”
    • “The story does not end in a way that is happy or sad, it does not highlight certain themes or messages, it barely follows an idea of slow escalation into mystery and instead leaves you confused from the first cut-scene.”
  • graphics
    678 mentions Positive Neutral Negative

    The graphics of "Puzzle Agent" feature a charming hand-drawn art style that evokes a quirky, cartoonish aesthetic reminiscent of newspaper comics. While many players appreciate the unique visuals and their fit with the game's atmosphere, some criticize the graphics for being simplistic or occasionally pixelated, which can detract from the overall experience. Overall, the art style is a defining feature of the game, contributing to its quirky humor and engaging narrative, despite some technical limitations.

    • “I absolutely loved the art style and the voice acting; it really got that weird upstate town in the middle of nowhere kind of feel.”
    • “The graphics may not be the sharpest, but they perfectly suit the game's almost chalkboard-like art style, which features some zany characters that will keep you entertained throughout.”
    • “The art style is amazing, the puzzles are so tight I remember them 6 years later, and the writing is snappy.”
    • “The graphics quality is frankly bad.”
    • “The puzzles are also graphically unappealing - the in-game story/adventure sections give way to single static screens for each puzzle, without any moving elements (uncontrolled by the player at least) and an overall board game-type look.”
    • “It actually makes a lot of puzzles harder because you can't tell what's a graphics hiccup and what's a single pixel that's out of place and preventing you from solving the puzzle.”
  • humor
    648 mentions Positive Neutral Negative

    The humor in "Puzzle Agent" is widely praised for its quirky, dark, and often absurd nature, drawing comparisons to the works of David Lynch and the Coen Brothers. Players appreciate the clever dialogue, strange characters, and the balance of lightheartedness with eerie undertones, which contribute to a unique and engaging experience. While some found the humor hit-or-miss, many enjoyed the game's ability to elicit genuine laughter through its witty writing and bizarre scenarios.

    • “The humor is subdued, mostly down-to-earth and character-based, with the occasional bouts of weirdness using contrast and shock very effectively to hit above their wit class.”
    • “This is a comedic gem with tons of different puzzles, which masterfully balances eerie mysteries with absurdly funny moments.”
    • “The dialogue is often witty, and the awkward social interactions between Nelson and the residents add a humorous touch.”
  • gameplay
    304 mentions Positive Neutral Negative

    The gameplay of this title is heavily inspired by the Professor Layton series, featuring a mix of point-and-click mechanics and a variety of puzzles that range in difficulty. While many players appreciate the engaging story and quirky humor, some criticize the puzzles for being overly simplistic or repetitive, with a linear structure that limits exploration. Overall, the game offers a short but enjoyable experience, particularly for fans of puzzle-solving, though it may not provide enough challenge or depth for all players.

    • “The puzzles range from short word problems and logic puzzles to rotation puzzles and string puzzles, providing a wide variety of mechanics and difficulties.”
    • “The gameplay is a lot like the Professor Layton series, so if you like that, you should really enjoy the puzzles in this one.”
    • “With a gameplay really similar to that of the Professor Layton series, and with a more than obvious influence on Twin Peaks, Puzzle Agent offers a short (around 3 hours), interesting and entertaining adventure accessible for anyone, even beginners with no experience on puzzle or logic games.”
    • “The gameplay itself is actually pretty boring and entirely unchallenging.”
    • “Once you get into a puzzle, gameplay is halted until you complete it, which is annoying, and on top of that, it is oftentimes a stretch in relating the puzzle to the actual game in the first place (making them seem pointless).”
    • “There's no real gameplay to speak of, you move from one location to the next in a very proscribed pattern and there's more bits of bubblegum to click than actual story elements.”
  • atmosphere
    234 mentions Positive Neutral Negative

    The atmosphere of "Puzzle Agent" is widely praised for its unique blend of eerie, whimsical, and mysterious elements, often drawing comparisons to the styles of "Twin Peaks" and "Fargo." Players appreciate the game's art direction, sound design, and voice acting, which collectively create an immersive experience that enhances the storytelling. Despite some criticism regarding the simplicity of the puzzles, the overall atmosphere is considered a standout feature that captivates players and keeps them engaged throughout the game.

    • “The atmosphere manages to be both playful and terrifying (seriously)!”
    • “I love the story and the artwork; the style really lends itself to the eerie and downright creepy atmosphere.”
    • “It's got an eerie, well-realized atmosphere (think Fargo mixed with Twin Peaks), a cool art/animation style, and puzzles that usually aren't too hard or too easy.”
    • “This unsettling atmosphere runs throughout the entire game, which unfortunately ends on a massive cliffhanger.”
    • “The tone is also weirdly inconsistent, like it can't decide if its atmosphere should be one of comedy, horror, or an off-putting mystery like Layton.”
    • “There's little time for the atmosphere and mood to set in.”
  • music
    204 mentions Positive Neutral Negative

    The music in the game is generally praised for its ability to create an atmospheric and immersive experience, with many reviewers noting its haunting and eerie qualities that complement the game's quirky narrative and art style. While some found the soundtrack memorable and fitting, others felt it was unremarkable or easily overlooked, serving more to enhance the overall ambiance rather than stand out on its own. Overall, the music contributes significantly to the game's unique charm, despite mixed opinions on its memorability.

    • “The music is great, the melodies will certainly stick in your head for good reasons and they support the sinister atmosphere.”
    • “Puzzle Agent has a beautiful pastel art style, a haunting soundtrack, and a bizarre story that is very reminiscent of Twin Peaks.”
    • “Great atmosphere created through the music, and the art style and bare-bones voice work really worked well together.”
    • “The music is nothing to write home about, but it sets the tone well.”
    • “It's not a strong point of the game, but when music is drawn into focus to make scenes more alive it works well.”
    • “The sound quality and music were at an acceptable, but not very impressive level.”
  • replayability
    90 mentions Positive Neutral Negative

    Overall, the game has very low to nonexistent replayability, with many players noting that once puzzles are solved, they are easily remembered, diminishing the incentive to replay. While the story and characters are enjoyable for a single playthrough, the lack of choices, randomization, and challenging content means that most players do not find value in revisiting the game. The experience is described as fun but short, typically lasting around 3 to 7 hours, leaving little reason to return after completion.

    • “It has quite a bit of replay value, as I feel as if most people may miss a few things the first playthrough.”
    • “There's also the replayability value of trying to get a perfect score.”
    • “Would play again if the replay value was higher (forgetting the solutions is hard).”
    • “Replayability is sadly nonexistent, with static puzzles and no decision points to reconsider.”
    • “The main negatives are that the game is quite short (I beat it in around 4 hours) and there is zero replay value whatsoever after you've beaten the game aside from redoing the puzzles, which you can't improve your score on unless you start a new game anyway.”
    • “Charming little adventure game with nice visuals, quirky story, haunting music and zero replayability.”
  • emotional
    18 mentions Positive Neutral Negative

    The emotional aspect of "Puzzle Agent" is mixed; while some players appreciate the charming art and the potential for deeper character connections, many feel that the story lacks resolution and fails to fully engage them emotionally. The abrupt ending left some feeling cheated, and the limited time with characters hinders emotional investment. Overall, while the game has its merits, it struggles to deliver a satisfying emotional experience compared to other titles in the genre.

    • “The art is created by a renowned artist who holds incredibly charming and emotionally deep visuals that help connect the player to the characters of the story.”
    • “Puzzle Agent - the puzzles are decent, but the story is absolute genius. The more you play, the more emotionally involved you get with the characters, right up to the abrupt, yet timely end... then you see Puzzle Agent 2!”
    • “Puzzle Agent is a smart, dark, and intriguing puzzler that made me feel dumb at some points, and is definitely worth a look.”
  • stability
    16 mentions Positive Neutral Negative

    The game's stability has received mixed reviews, with many players reporting significant bugs and glitches, particularly on Windows 10 and macOS, leading to unplayable experiences for some. While a few users noted minor issues and overall enjoyable gameplay, the prevalence of freezing and graphical problems detracts from the experience for many. Overall, the game appears to struggle with stability across various platforms.

    • “A fun concept, but a very buggy run for an established game (could be that it's just not happy running on Windows 11, though).”
    • “Unplayable on Windows 10 GTX 1650, freezes constantly.”
    • “Great...a game that looks like fun until the graphical glitches on Mac prevent you from playing.”
  • grinding
    14 mentions Positive Neutral Negative

    Reviews highlight a mixed experience with grinding in the game, noting that while the removal of tedious exploration in favor of frequent puzzles can enhance engagement, the slow text scrolling and lack of puzzle repetition can lead to frustration. Some players find the constant puzzle-solving enjoyable, while others feel it becomes monotonous and tedious over time. Overall, the grinding aspect is seen as a double-edged sword, balancing between engaging gameplay and potential frustration.

    • “I really expected to like and enjoy this game based on other reviews, but I found it frustrating and tedious.”
    • “You can't fast scroll through text - you have to choose between reading it the slow way or skipping it entirely - which makes the plot segments as tedious as the puzzling.”
    • “There is rarely a repeating puzzle design, which prevents the many puzzles from becoming tedious, but also makes it difficult to improve over the course of the game.”
  • optimization
    10 mentions Positive Neutral Negative

    The game is highly optimized for touchscreen devices, providing a smooth gameplay experience that enhances user engagement. Performance ratings are exceptional, with a perfect score of 10/10, indicating that technical execution is a strong point despite the linear nature of the game.

    • “The gameplay was very smooth, and clearly optimized for touchscreen.”
    • “Performance: 10/10”
    • “The gameplay was very smooth, and clearly optimized for touchscreen.”
  • character development
    6 mentions Positive Neutral Negative

    The game features strong character development complemented by a compelling story, with unique character designs by Graham Annable that enhance the overall experience. While the sketchy graphics may appear unconventional, they effectively contribute to the game's artistic charm.

    • “Good story and character development.”
    • “The sketchy graphics may seem unfinished or unusual, but they still look fine, and especially the unique character designs (done by Graham Annable, who also co-directed the Oscar-nominated animated movie 'The Boxtrolls') make the game.”
    • “The art, world, and character design are linked to Graham Annable.”

Buy Puzzle Agent

4h Median play time
4h Average play time
3-5h Spent by most gamers
*Based on 34 analyzed playthroughs

Videos

Games Like Puzzle Agent

Puzzle Agent 2 ImagePuzzle Agent 2 ImagePuzzle Agent 2 Image
Detective Grimoire ImageDetective Grimoire ImageDetective Grimoire Image
Detective Grimoire Image
The Tiny Bang Story Image
Tormentum: Dark Sorrow Image
Truberbrook / Trüberbrook Image
Edna & Harvey: Harvey's New Eyes Image
Kathy Rain Image
Deponia Image
Agatha Christie: The ABC Murders Image