Primal Carnage: Extinction

The optimization of "Primal Carnage" has received mixed reviews, with many players reporting significant performance issues, including stuttering and lag, even on lower graphical settings. While some updates have improved optimization for certain users, others still experience poor performance and bugs, leading to frustration within the community. Overall, the game appears to struggle with optimization compared to its predecessor, despite some players noting improvements in graphics and performance over time.

The humor in the game is widely appreciated, with players finding the antics of dinosaurs, ragdoll physics, and various in-game taunts to be consistently hilarious. Many reviews highlight the fun of playing with friends, where wacky humor enhances the experience, while others enjoy the game's silly references and creative player interactions. Despite some criticisms regarding bugs and gameplay balance, the overall sentiment is that the game delivers a lighthearted and entertaining experience.

The game's story aspect is widely criticized, with many players noting a lack of a coherent narrative or engaging storyline. While some missions and game modes offer a semblance of plot, the overall consensus is that the game feels more like a series of disconnected challenges rather than a cohesive story experience. Players express a desire for a more developed single-player story mode and additional content to enhance the narrative depth.

The monetization model of the game has drawn significant criticism, with many players feeling it relies heavily on microtransactions for cosmetic items, which detracts from the overall experience. While some appreciate the lack of predatory practices like gambling mechanics, the overwhelming presence of expensive skins and a perceived focus on profit over gameplay quality has led to claims of it being a cash grab. Overall, the game's monetization strategy is seen as a major flaw, contributing to a lack of player engagement and dissatisfaction with the developers' priorities.

The grinding aspect of the game is generally viewed as tedious and time-consuming, particularly for players seeking skins and rank-ups, with some noting it can become boring if not fully engaged. While there are alternative methods to acquire cosmetics, many players express frustration over repetitive rewards and the need for extensive grinding, often leading to a reliance on item farming servers. Despite these challenges, some find the grind rewarding, especially when finally obtaining desired skins.

Overall, the game's replayability is mixed; while some players find it infinitely replayable due to enjoyable customization and leveling systems, others feel it becomes repetitive without a progression system or unlockables. The potential for future updates, including new modes and playable species, could enhance replay value significantly.

The game's soundtrack has received positive feedback, with players highlighting its enjoyable and fitting music that enhances the gaming experience, particularly during human gameplay. The inclusion of tracks like "madness combat" adds to the fun, making the music a standout feature even in solo play. Overall, the music is described as great and well-suited to various situations within the game.

The emotional aspect of the game is mixed; while some players appreciate the wholesome community and supportive interactions, others highlight a persistent toxic environment that detracts from the overall experience. The gifting system is seen as a positive feature that fosters connection, but the presence of long-standing negative behaviors raises concerns about mental safety for players.

The atmosphere of the game is described as engaging and immersive, particularly in competitive modes like team deathmatch, where players feel fully enveloped in their roles, whether as a dinosaur or a human. However, some users criticize the overall atmosphere as lacking tension and depth, comparing it unfavorably to the original Primal Carnage, which offered a darker and more atmospheric experience.

Reviews indicate that character development in the game is perceived as lacking depth, with a focus on unrealistic and immature designs rather than meaningful growth or complexity. Players express a desire for more mature and nuanced character portrayals, contrasting sharply with the comical aesthetics reminiscent of Borderlands 2.