Outlaws of the Old West
- March 12, 2019
- Virtual Basement LLC
- 16h median play time
Outlaws of the Old West is a open-world survival game set in the Wild West. Create your own character and build your own town, or roam the lands as a lone wolf, hunting, trading, and fighting for survival. Join factions, complete missions, and navigate the moral complexities of frontier life in this immersive and gritty simulator.
Reviews
- The game has a lot of potential and offers a unique Wild West survival experience.
- Crafting and building mechanics are enjoyable and allow for creativity.
- The game features a large open world with beautiful landscapes to explore.
- The game is plagued by numerous bugs and glitches that hinder gameplay.
- There is a lack of content and objectives, leading to repetitive gameplay.
- The game has been abandoned by the developers, with no updates or support.
- stability284 mentions
- 2 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 98 % negative mentions
The game's stability is a significant concern, with numerous players reporting a wide range of bugs and glitches that impact gameplay, including freezing, lag, and unresponsive mechanics. While some users acknowledge that these issues are typical for early access titles and express enjoyment despite the problems, many others find the game nearly unplayable due to its instability. Overall, the consensus is that while the game has potential, it requires substantial improvements in stability and optimization before it can be recommended.
“The mechanics were well thought out, the concept is amazing, and the overall gameplay really wasn't buggy at all for me.”
“Original review from mid-2020: this game runs well for me (16GB RAM; GTX 1080 Ti), no freezes, crashes, etc. The building aspect of the game feels very much like early Ark.”
“If you want a complete game that is bug-free and is in full release, this is not the game for you...”
“The game is a buggy mess.”
“Ridiculously buggy and unpolished, the game is all but unplayable.”
“There are hard-hitting bugs and glitches right now that are making this game virtually unplayable.”
- graphics217 mentions
- 51 % positive mentions
- 42 % neutral mentions
- 7 % negative mentions
The graphics of the game receive mixed reviews, with many players praising the beautiful landscapes, smooth performance on high-end systems, and appealing aesthetics. However, there are significant criticisms regarding optimization issues, outdated visuals, and frequent graphical bugs that detract from the overall experience. While some players find the graphics satisfactory for an early access title, others feel they fall short of expectations set by promotional materials and trailers.
“The graphics are beautiful, from land to sky, and the water always looks good, making it feel realistic.”
“The graphics and scenery are amazing; you have a huge map with lots of wildlife.”
“The graphics are fantastic, and the scenery is breathtaking.”
“The graphics look like they are from the early 00's and it looks nothing like in the trailer.”
“I have played this for many hours and a year after the release into alpha, nothing has been done to improve the graphics.”
“The graphics are absolutely terrible, and I refunded.”
- gameplay201 mentions
- 26 % positive mentions
- 68 % neutral mentions
- 6 % negative mentions
The gameplay of the game has received mixed reviews, with many praising its solid mechanics and immersive crafting system, reminiscent of titles like Ark and Conan. However, numerous players have reported significant bugs, crashes, and issues with building mechanics that detract from the overall experience. While some find the gameplay enjoyable and engaging, especially in cooperative settings, others express frustration over the game's unfinished state and lack of polish.
“The mechanics were well thought out, the concept is amazing, and the overall gameplay really wasn't buggy at all for me.”
“The core gameplay is solid and the building aspect of the game is far better than I expected.”
“The gameplay is fun and there seems to be a deep crafting system.”
“Dead game full of bugs and unstable extreme lagging gameplay.”
“The mechanics of this game are pretty similar to Conan Exiles, which I loved.”
“Gameplay is very buggy and there's not really much point to the game other than building all the stuff.”
- optimization117 mentions
- 15 % positive mentions
- 52 % neutral mentions
- 33 % negative mentions
Overall, the game's optimization has received significant criticism, with many players reporting severe performance issues, including lag, stuttering, and low frame rates even on high-end systems. While some users noted that the game runs adequately on lower settings, the consensus is that it requires major optimization improvements to enhance gameplay and stability. Despite its potential, many recommend waiting for further updates before purchasing due to its current state of poor optimization.
“But for the most part it was really optimized even in 4K 60, a lot of stuff worked as intended.”
“Granted that we have decent PCs, the performance of this game is kind of good.”
“The game is very well optimized with minor bugs that are common to early access.”
“The game needed serious performance updates.”
“This game has terrible optimization, despite the fact that the graphics don't look impressive in 2019-2020.”
“I finally get the chance to play, and not only have I found that after all these updates, the game has still not been optimized, but it's now so laggy and glitchy that it's entirely unplayable.”
- grinding107 mentions
- 3 % positive mentions
- 3 % neutral mentions
- 94 % negative mentions
The grinding aspect of the game has received mixed feedback from players. While some appreciate the balance of resource gathering and crafting, noting that it isn't excessively tedious compared to other survival games, others find it can become monotonous and frustrating, especially when technical issues lead to lost progress. Overall, players enjoy the immersive environment and community aspects, but many express a desire for improvements in farming mechanics and more engaging content to reduce the feeling of endless grinding.
“The map is huge, building and crafting is solid, not too grindy, but enough to bring satisfaction upon completing personal projects.”
“Pretty good for a survival, not too grindy until you get to a brick building.”
“It's not too grindy so you can easily gather resources and start building some nice things pretty quickly.”
“You'll need a second life for grinding.”
“Nothing to buy or find, just grinding is all you do.”
“After days of painful and boring grinding for resources and building quite an exquisite/expensive base, my character and all his belongings vanished from one of the official servers.”
- story78 mentions
- 10 % positive mentions
- 76 % neutral mentions
- 14 % negative mentions
The game's story aspect is widely criticized for its lack of narrative depth, quests, and engaging NPCs, leaving players feeling that the world is empty and directionless. Many reviewers express a desire for a structured storyline or mission system to enhance gameplay and provide a sense of purpose, as the current experience is primarily focused on survival and crafting without any overarching plot. While some enjoy the sandbox elements, the consensus is that the game needs significant improvements in story content to fully realize its potential.
“I think the base of the game is perfect, but it needs some more add-ins to help build a story (what happened? why are you there? why are you trying to stay alive? etc).”
“If the devs can introduce quests and other reasons to progress in the game, along with some interesting NPC locations, then this game could make one of the prettiest and most engrossing open-world games on the market.”
“I just wish there was a story to follow or objectives.”
“It's too bad they didn't want to finish it because the part they did is pretty nice, reminds me of Conan Exiles but with no story, so it feels even more empty and pointless.”
“Lacks any kind of story or quests, which is disappointing.”
“There are no quests in this game, and there is no story.”
- monetization25 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 4 % neutral mentions
- 96 % negative mentions
The monetization aspect of the game has been heavily criticized, with users labeling it as a "cash grab" due to its abandonment and lack of support after initial sales. Many reviewers express disappointment over the game's unfinished state and buggy mechanics, suggesting that the developers prioritized profit over quality and player experience. Overall, the sentiment is overwhelmingly negative, with strong warnings against purchasing the game.
“This game had a lot of potential at the start and then over time I saw the reviews of this game go from positive to mixed and now to negative. It's such a shame how they abandoned this project without warning, at this point it's just a cash grab for them to still have some backup income.”
“Let me be clear, do not buy this cash grab, unfinished joke of a game.”
“I stopped playing this game well in advance of its demise as I saw the direction it was going and knew that it was just nothing but a cash grab. The development seemed like a college project made by students, with no graphical improvement, no major bug fixes, just more content with bugs on top of other remaining bugs.”
- humor19 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The humor in the game is largely derived from its numerous bugs and glitches, which players find amusing rather than frustrating, such as flying animals and NPCs with erratic movements. While the game's mechanics and AI need significant improvement, the unintended comedic moments—like characters getting stuck or absurd interactions—provide a source of entertainment. Overall, players seem to appreciate the humor in the game's shortcomings, often laughing at its flaws rather than with it.
“I find it hilarious that you can jump 12 feet and die, but plummet off the highest mountain and run back to camp.”
“It was hilarious watching the bandits jump and run about.”
“They can actually be quite funny, like horses getting stuck in the ground or furniture floating in the air (causing a few townsfolk to believe in witches haha).”
- music15 mentions
- 40 % positive mentions
- 40 % neutral mentions
- 20 % negative mentions
The music in the game is generally well-received, with players appreciating its ability to enhance the western atmosphere and immersive experience. While the soundtrack features enjoyable themes that fit the setting, some users noted that repetitive listening during long loading times can detract from the experience. Overall, the music contributes positively to the game's ambiance, making it a highlight for many players.
“The game had so much potential and beautiful scenery, music, and themes.”
“The music is actually pleasant to listen to and it doesn't loop over and over until you're sick of it.”
“This game also nails the 'western' environment down with its large map and ambient music.”
“The soundtrack consists of a couple of themes that randomly turn on when you're passing a trigger area.”
“Decent music and western sound effects.”
“Otherwise, I love the music and the atmosphere of the game.”
- atmosphere13 mentions
- 62 % positive mentions
- 15 % neutral mentions
- 23 % negative mentions
The game's atmosphere is generally praised for its beauty and relaxing qualities, effectively capturing a true Wild West vibe. However, some players feel it lacks dynamic weather effects and additional environmental details, which could enhance immersion. Overall, while the atmosphere contributes positively to the gameplay experience, there are suggestions for improvements to make it even more engaging.
“It's a chill, atmospheric game that is fun to return to sometimes.”
“The atmosphere is perfectly conducive to the theme.”
“Been playing this early access game for nearly 20 hours and have to say it's one of the best early access titles out there; a lot of crafting, leveling, and great atmosphere brings a lot of gameplay that I am really enjoying.”
“Could have been a fun game; it has a lot going for it in certain departments, and the atmosphere and pace of the game are attractive, but it falls totally flat in other areas.”
“Needs some more props around the empty fields, maybe some abandoned cities with some loot, etc. Also, the lighting is kind of weird, and the colors look washed out, which makes the whole atmosphere look dull.”
“The environment, animals, and atmosphere are pretty well done.”
- replayability6 mentions
- 33 % positive mentions
- 17 % neutral mentions
- 50 % negative mentions
The game's replayability is mixed; while some players find high replay value, especially in private RP servers, others feel it lacks depth and becomes boring without engaging updates or community support. Recent improvements have made the game more playable, but ongoing developer attention is crucial for maintaining player interest. Overall, the potential for replayability exists, but it heavily depends on community engagement and developer responsiveness.
“High replay value.”
“After numerous updates in less than a week, the game is substantially more playable online (the developers have been doing awesome!).”
“I truly feel these changes would add way more replay value and keep people engaged; otherwise, it gets boring after a bit.”
“I wish this game would have succeeded as I really like the concept, but it seems like the devs or anyone with pull within the company don't really care what their customer base wants them to fix to make the game better and more playable.”
“It is true that this launch was smoother and more playable than Ark, Conan, or Atlas, but the game still has its issues.”
- character development3 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- -67 % neutral mentions
- 67 % negative mentions
Character development in the game shows potential but remains underdeveloped, with many crafting options not yet impacting gameplay significantly, such as cooking recipes lacking effects on stamina or skill progression. While the game improves on certain aspects from its predecessor, Ark, the overall character development experience feels incomplete and is an area that players hope will be enhanced in future updates.
“This is a game I enjoyed so much; the building options, though unfinished, have a great feel to them. The character development - well, the shell is there; it'd be good to see this worked on.”
“Crafting is in the early stages, offering a wide variety of cooking, carpentry, metalworking, ammunition and explosives, tailoring, etc. Not all of these make full use of enhancements to character development yet (i.e., the thirty or forty cooking recipes offer no changes to stamina, skill leveling up, etc. yet, but we expect to see that in the future).”
“The similarities to Ark are not surprising, considering the developers' past involvement in that game. While I do think this initial release improves on some of Ark's faults (namely UI design, character design, and player animations), there are some major weak points.”
“Crafting is in the early stages, offering a wide variety of cooking, carpentry, metalworking, ammunition and explosives, tailoring, etc. However, not all of these make full use of enhancements to character development yet. For example, the thirty or forty cooking recipes offer no changes to stamina or skill leveling up, but we expect that to improve in the future.”
“The similarities to Ark are not surprising, considering the developers' past involvement in that game. While I do think this initial release improves on some of Ark's faults, such as UI design, character design, and player animations, there are regrettably some major weak points. The world design is utterly forgettable, and while some vistas look good thanks to UE4's lighting and volumetric effects, the randomness of prop placement and the lack of visual believability and readability are extremely disappointing in a wild west game.”