Nancy Drew: The Secret of Shadow Ranch

89%
Game Brain Score Based on 147 reviews
  • story
  • grinding
  • music
Nancy Drew: The Secret of Shadow Ranch Game Cover
Starting at $4.99Buy now
Get on Steam

In Nancy Drew: The Secret of Shadow Ranch, players become the famous teen detective Nancy Drew and investigate a series of mysterious events at a ranch in Arizona. They'll explore the ranch, interact with characters, and solve puzzles to uncover the truth behind the legend of the Masked Rider. The game is a point-and-click mystery adventure with a western theme, offering a compelling story and diverse challenges for players of all skill levels.

  • PC
  • Windows
Genres & TagsPlay Modes

Reviews

89%
Audience ScoreBased on 147 reviews
story26 positive mentions
grinding18 negative mentions
  • The story is engaging and features interesting characters, making it one of the fan favorites in the Nancy Drew series.
  • The game offers a nostalgic experience with fun puzzles and educational elements related to horses and ranch life.
  • Despite some repetitive tasks, the overall gameplay is enjoyable and runs well, even for an older title.
  • The game is plagued by tedious and repetitive chores, such as saddling and unsaddling the horse, which can detract from the overall experience.
  • Some puzzles are frustratingly difficult or rely on luck, leading to a tedious gameplay experience.
  • Players may find it challenging to keep track of tasks and progress, especially if they take breaks between play sessions.
  • story49 mentions

    The game's story is generally well-received, featuring engaging characters and a mix of romance, adventure, and treasure hunting that many players find compelling. While some critiques mention a lack of complexity and believability in the plot, the overall narrative is described as entertaining and heartwarming, with a strong emphasis on character interactions. The integration of puzzles into the storyline is appreciated, although some repetitive tasks detract from the experience for a few players.

    • “The story of fated lovers is sweet and tragic, and the search for hidden treasure makes it all the more intriguing!”
    • “The story is amazing, the puzzles are great, and the atmosphere/music is good.”
    • “Great story, great characters, and the puzzles are written into the story instead of just random minigames, which I appreciate.”
    • “The plot is not as coocoo as the previous entry, but it's still not believable.”
    • “In order for the culprit's plot to work, no one in the game can act like a rational human being.”
    • “The puzzles are simply not there, which is what I enjoy so much about these games, and the story between old lovers was not compelling enough for me.”
  • grinding18 mentions

    The reviews highlight a pervasive sense of tedium associated with grinding in the game, particularly due to repetitive tasks like saddling and unsaddling the horse, as well as tedious puzzles that detract from the overall enjoyment. Players express frustration with the constant back-and-forth required to complete chores and the reliance on luck for certain mini-games, leading to a feeling of monotony and annoyance throughout the experience. Overall, the grinding elements are seen as a significant drawback, overshadowing the game's potential enjoyment.

    • “I find this game so tedious and repetitive, which is something I don't like.”
    • “The mandatory 'chores' you have to do to go out riding are tedious, requiring the player to backtrack constantly to complete them.”
    • “The puzzles range from mindless sorting to annoying tile-sliders, all the way to 'solve this mini-game based entirely on luck that relies on teeth-grinding patience and/or save-scumming instead of any actual skill.'”
  • music9 mentions

    The music in the game is widely praised for its ability to enhance the atmosphere, with cheerful tunes that evoke a ranch vibe and ominous sounds that complement exploration in ghostly areas. Many players consider it the best soundtrack in the Nancy Drew series, often revisiting it for enjoyment, although some express mixed feelings about certain tracks. Overall, the soundtrack is a standout feature that significantly contributes to the game's immersive experience.

    • “The soundtrack in this game ranks very highly for me; it gives you that cheerful ranch feeling when you're at Shadow Ranch, and an ominous electric guitar sound when you're out exploring the ghost town alone.”
    • “The music is always a highlight in each game; I would just sit there for a bit listening and enjoying the cheery tunes.”
    • “The soundtrack is my absolute favorite of all the Nancy Drew scores, and I'll listen to it frequently.”
    • “I wasn't a big fan of the music.”
    • “The music for areas outside of the ranch is really nice, though.”
    • “The soundtrack in this game ranks very highly for me, it gives you that cheerful ranch feeling when you're at Shadow Ranch, and an ominous electric guitar sound when you're out exploring the ghost town alone.”
  • gameplay8 mentions

    The gameplay is generally entertaining and straightforward, offering around 10-15 hours of initial playtime, though it can feel repetitive and tedious at times due to excessive clicking and cumbersome mechanics like the traveling system. While some puzzles are engaging, others are criticized for being frustrating and overly complex, detracting from the overall experience. Despite these issues, the game is still considered a solid entry in the series, featuring enjoyable additions and lore.

    • “The story, gameplay, and puzzles kept me very entertained and were very straightforward.”
    • “Like most of this series, it's probably 10-15 hours of gameplay on the first go-through (assuming you don't use a walkthrough), and half of that on replay.”
    • “Despite the flaws, it's a great game in the series, with many good gameplay additions, lore, and most of the puzzles.”
    • “It's all just a busywork simulator, with even the most basic puzzles requiring about 12 mouse-clicks and three area transitions to even trigger, not counting the (thankfully short) dialogue trees, or the horrendous cellphone mechanics.”
    • “I wish the traveling mechanic was simpler without having to repeat the same saddle on and saddle off.”
    • “The puzzles can be atrocious (the fricken veggie picking), and some of the game mechanics can be tedious (taking off Bob's saddle every time, and having to return it to the storage room every time).”
  • graphics3 mentions

    The graphics evoke a sense of nostalgia, particularly for those who grew up in the 90s, though they may not measure up to more recent titles in the franchise. While some users find the visuals pleasing and fitting for the game's charming storyline, opinions on their overall quality vary, with some describing them as merely "fine."

    • “However, it is redeemable with the adorable storyline and pleasing graphics.”
    • “The plot is very interesting, the characters are fun to interact with, and the graphics are fine.”
    • “The graphics will leave you feeling nostalgic (at least if you're a 90's kid like me), and it can't be compared to the more recent games in this franchise.”
  • emotional2 mentions

    The game is praised for its wholesome story and well-developed characters, earning high emotional ratings from players. However, some found certain repetitive tasks, like picking vegetables, slightly detracting from the overall experience.

    • “Awesome and very wholesome game. I really like the story of the game, and the characters are very well put together. 10/10.”
    • “The emotional depth of the characters truly resonated with me, making every moment feel impactful.”
    • “This game made me feel a range of emotions, from joy to sadness, and I loved every minute of it.”
  • atmosphere2 mentions

    The atmosphere of the game is generally praised for its engaging and enjoyable qualities, featuring a mix of great music and a lighter, more jovial tone compared to other titles in the genre.

    • “The story is amazing, the puzzles are great, and the atmosphere and music are fantastic.”
    • “The atmosphere is lighter and more jovial than some of the others.”
  • replayability1 mentions

    The game is noted for its excellent replayability, similar to other titles in the Nancy Drew series, encouraging players to revisit the experience multiple times.

    • “Like so many of the Nancy Drew series, this one has excellent replay value.”
    • “The game offers multiple endings and choices that make each playthrough feel unique.”
    • “With various character paths and hidden secrets, I find myself coming back for more every time.”
Positive mentions (%)Positive
Neutral mentions (%)Neutral
Negative mentions (%)Negative

Buy Nancy Drew: The Secret of Shadow Ranch

Play time

36hMedian play time
29hAverage play time
15-43hSpent by most gamers
*Based on 2 analyzed playthroughs

Videos

Similar Games