Muck
- June 5, 2021
- DEVENILLA
- 8h median play time
Get on Steam
Get on itch.io Store"Muck" is a game containing a challenging end-game boss, a mix of ME, Benten, and Dragon ballyea, considered as hard as Bob. To summon this boss, you need two guardian gems to unlock its shrine. Defeating it requires striking it again within 5 seconds of the initial hit, triggering its special attack for increased damage output.
Mac OS
PC
Windows
Cloud
Linux
NVIDIA GeForce NOW
Reviews
- humor1,689 mentions
- 99 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 1 % negative mentions
The humor in "Muck" is widely praised for its absurdity and childlike charm, often drawing comparisons to meme culture and internet humor. Players find the game particularly funny when played with friends, as chaotic moments and unexpected challenges lead to laughter and memorable experiences. The game's quirky character designs, silly item descriptions, and humorous mechanics contribute to its overall comedic appeal, making it a lighthearted and entertaining experience despite its challenging gameplay.
“It's like Minecraft meets Dark Souls—but with more hilarious deaths, confusing weapon choices, and a general sense of 'what on earth is happening?'”
“It’s honestly hilarious how often the low taper fade meme pops up while you're furiously crafting a pickaxe and trying to fend off an army of goblins.”
“The unpredictable nature of the game makes for some truly hilarious and unforgettable moments.”
“Minecraft if it was made by unfunny millennials.”
“Knockoff version of Rust with incredibly unfunny jokes.”
“Filled with unfunny humor for 10-year-olds who overuse the word 'irony'.”
- gameplay1,344 mentions
- 38 % positive mentions
- 57 % neutral mentions
- 5 % negative mentions
The gameplay of "Muck" is characterized by its unique blend of survival mechanics and roguelike elements, offering a challenging yet engaging experience. Players appreciate the straightforward mechanics and cooperative gameplay, though many express a desire for more depth, content updates, and a save feature to enhance the overall experience. While the game is fun and addictive, especially in multiplayer, some find the difficulty spikes and lack of building utility frustrating, leading to a mixed reception regarding its long-term replayability.
“Muck's gameplay is quite diverse; players will experience the true feeling of survival when having to search for food and water, build shelters, and fight dangerous creatures.”
“The mechanics are straightforward enough to keep anyone engaged, but there’s enough depth to satisfy even the most seasoned of survival game players.”
“The whimsical yet challenging gameplay keeps you hooked, and the sense of progression is incredibly satisfying.”
“The gameplay is extremely subtle, and without a solid grasp of theoretical physics most of the features will go over a typical gamer's head.”
“The entire gameplay loop feels uninspired and lackluster.”
“The building mechanics are completely useless.”
- graphics925 mentions
- 37 % positive mentions
- 56 % neutral mentions
- 7 % negative mentions
The graphics of "Muck" have received mixed reviews, with many players appreciating its simplistic, low-poly art style that evokes nostalgia for classic indie games. While some criticize the visuals as lacking detail and polish, others find the colorful and quirky graphics charming and fitting for the game's lighthearted tone. Overall, the graphics are deemed functional and accessible, allowing the game to run smoothly even on lower-end hardware, which contributes to its appeal as a fun multiplayer experience.
“From the moment I jumped in, I was captivated by its vibrant art style and engaging gameplay mechanics.”
“The vibrant colors and simple, blocky style give the game a unique aesthetic that is both nostalgic and fresh.”
“Despite its simple graphics, 'muck' manages to create a mesmerizing world that feels truly alive.”
“The graphics are so bad, they might as well have been drawn by a toddler with crayons.”
“Graphically, the game falls short in almost every conceivable way, failing to meet even the most basic standards of visual appeal that are now commonplace in the industry.”
“The art style, while potentially unique, is poorly executed and inconsistent, leading to a disjointed visual experience.”
- story531 mentions
- 20 % positive mentions
- 68 % neutral mentions
- 12 % negative mentions
The game's story has received mixed reviews, with some players praising it as a beautiful and revolutionary narrative that explores deep themes of humanity, while others criticize it for being incoherent or lacking depth. Many players appreciate the emotional impact and character development, but some feel that the gameplay overshadows the story, leading to a perception that it is minimal or poorly constructed. Overall, the narrative is seen as a significant aspect of the game, though opinions vary widely on its execution and effectiveness.
“It stays vibrant, fresh, and revolutionizes the art of storytelling and filmmaking while making a damn statement on what it means to be human.”
“The sheer magnitude of delight and fulfillment emanating from this extraordinary game exemplifies the transformative power of immersive storytelling and gameplay, cementing its status as an unforgettable experience that leaves an indelible mark on all who embark on this extraordinary journey of virtual enlightenment.”
“Muck's story not only critiques capitalism and the will for survival in a pre-industrial age society but it also challenges colonialism as you, as a player, are dropped into an unfamiliar world and are challenged with moral decisions on whether you should improve the lives of these peoples or conquer them for profit.”
“Characterized by a poorly constructed, incoherent, and often nonsensical storyline, the narrative lacks the depth, originality, and coherence needed to engage players on an emotional level.”
“Characters are poorly developed, dialogues are uninspired and repetitive, and the overall plot fails to provide the compelling motivations or emotional connections necessary to keep players invested.”
“This weak narrative framework severely undermines player immersion and engagement, as the storyline does not offer any meaningful context or motivation for the player’s actions within the game world.”
- grinding243 mentions
- 1 % positive mentions
- 35 % neutral mentions
- 64 % negative mentions
The reviews indicate that the game features significant grinding, often described as tedious and time-consuming, particularly due to the lack of a save function which forces players to complete sessions in one go. While some players enjoy the grind as part of the challenge, many find it frustrating, especially when combined with difficult combat and resource gathering that can feel repetitive. Overall, the grinding aspect is a polarizing feature, with some appreciating the depth it adds to gameplay, while others see it as a barrier to enjoyment.
“Progression in the game is very simple: take rock, chop wood, get better rock, chop better wood, get even better rock, chop even better wood, and so on. It works as it actually feels nice to progress and isn't too tedious for what it is. In the end, when you actually have nice stuff, you progress by defeating guardians instead, which mixes up the endgame!”
“It's not too grindy; the difficulty feels nice as you progress, and the game already has a baseline for a solid crafting/building system.”
“Although it's not grindy, it still takes time to progress, and since there is no saving, you can't just play the game over multiple days like with pretty much every other survival game.”
“You also can't save games, so you have to do everything in one play session, which makes the game feel tedious.”
“Every part of the game feels like a tedious task rather than an exciting process.”
“It sucks that when you spend a couple of hours playing the game, get a bit burnt out and want to play another game, but can't save, making all of those hours of grinding worthless.”
- replayability180 mentions
- 42 % positive mentions
- 52 % neutral mentions
- 6 % negative mentions
The game "Muck" is widely praised for its high replayability, primarily due to its procedural generation, diverse crafting options, and multiplayer capabilities, which keep each playthrough fresh and engaging. While many players find it enjoyable and addictive, some note that replay value diminishes after mastering the game or completing it multiple times, particularly due to limited content and progression systems. Overall, it offers a fun experience, especially with friends, but may require updates to maintain long-term replayability.
“Muck offers a substantial amount of content, with a focus on replayability and procedural generation.”
“The procedural generation of the world ensures that no two playthroughs are ever the same, giving the game incredible replayability.”
“Its dynamic world and multiplayer capabilities provide hours of entertainment, and its replay value stems from the unpredictable nature of the procedurally generated environment.”
“Moreover, the game's replayability is severely limited due to a lack of meaningful content and progression systems.”
“Fun indie game to play with friends, but has a low level of replayability as the game's content is limited.”
“After winning, the game loses replayability.”
- music172 mentions
- 29 % positive mentions
- 69 % neutral mentions
- 2 % negative mentions
The music in the game receives mixed reviews, with some players praising its emotional depth and ability to enhance the gameplay experience, while others find it repetitive and uninspired. Many appreciate the atmospheric soundtrack that complements the game's visuals, creating a charming and immersive environment, though some express disappointment over the limited variety of tracks. Overall, the music is seen as a significant aspect that can either elevate or detract from the gaming experience, depending on individual preferences.
“The soundtrack, composed of catchy tunes and atmospheric tracks, complements the gameplay perfectly, enhancing the overall experience.”
“Muck's pixelated graphics and atmospheric soundtrack create a charming and immersive environment.”
“The music in Muck is very good, but isn't very common.”
“The soundtrack is uninspired, repetitive, and often fails to match the tone or mood of the gameplay.”
“Background music, which should enhance the atmosphere, becomes monotonous and grating over time, adding to the overall sense of boredom and disengagement.”
“This game is the digital embodiment of that one song that you really like but at the same time you want to rip your ears off with a pair of rusty pliers when you hear it.”
- stability114 mentions
- 4 % positive mentions
- 2 % neutral mentions
- 94 % negative mentions
The game's stability is frequently criticized, with many users reporting numerous bugs, glitches, and crashes that disrupt gameplay and create frustration. While some players find the bugs endearing or amusing, the overall consensus is that the game is currently a "buggy mess" that needs significant improvements to enhance the experience. Despite these issues, there is a sense of optimism about the game's potential as it continues to develop.
“Runs great on low-end PCs as well!”
“I can't really find anything negative about this game, no glitches, not janky.”
“Now 100% bug free!”
“Frequent glitches, bugs, and crashes disrupt the gameplay experience, causing frustration and hindering progress.”
“The game is also a horrendously buggy mess.”
“This game is shit, it is very hard, very buggy and straight up bad.”
- emotional108 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The emotional aspect of the game is a significant highlight, with many players expressing deep connections to its narrative and characters, often leading to tears of joy or sadness. While some reviews note a lack of coherence in the storyline, others praise its heartwarming moments and the ability to evoke a wide range of emotions, from laughter to profound sadness. Overall, the game is described as an emotionally impactful experience that resonates with players, making them feel both joy and pain throughout their journey.
“That part truly made me shed a tear.”
“This game made me cry when I had to save the planet from a giant dragon and there was a cutscene where I remembered my family and kids and why I was where I was.”
“This game touched me on an emotional level like no other.”
- optimization88 mentions
- 33 % positive mentions
- 51 % neutral mentions
- 16 % negative mentions
The game's optimization has received mixed reviews, with many players reporting significant performance issues, including high resource usage and lag, particularly on lower-end systems. While some users noted that the minimalist visual style helps maintain performance, others experienced severe stuttering and crashes, leading to frustration. Overall, the consensus suggests that while the game can be enjoyable, it requires substantial optimization improvements to enhance stability and performance across various hardware configurations.
“The game generally performs well on a range of systems.”
“Enjoyable and well optimized game, can recommend for everyone.”
“Overall, this game is silly and goofy, while also being a pretty optimized game, with fun and well-designed mechanics.”
“Compounding these significant issues are a host of performance problems that plague the game from start to finish.”
“Sufficed to say, this game will not run on most systems due to the lack of optimization.”
“Extremely badly optimized; other than that, it's a good game but could be way better optimized.”
- atmosphere30 mentions
- 57 % positive mentions
- 33 % neutral mentions
- 10 % negative mentions
The atmosphere of the game is characterized by a unique blend of lightheartedness and survival elements, creating an engaging and immersive experience. Players appreciate the charming low-poly art style and atmospheric soundtrack, which enhance the overall enjoyment, although some find the background music can become monotonous over time. While the game offers moments of tranquility, it can shift to intense gameplay, contributing to a dynamic and captivating virtual environment.
“The lighthearted tone combined with the survival elements creates a unique atmosphere that’s both relaxing and exhilarating.”
“The soundtrack, composed of catchy tunes and atmospheric tracks, complements the gameplay perfectly, enhancing the overall experience.”
“Together, the visual and auditory elements create an immersive and enjoyable atmosphere.”
“Background music, which should enhance the atmosphere, becomes monotonous and grating over time, adding to the overall sense of boredom and disengagement.”
“Atmosphere: this game was made in a few days, so it's (bad).”
“❎ fair: basic sound/music, doesn't enhance the atmosphere.”
- monetization28 mentions
- 18 % positive mentions
- 46 % neutral mentions
- 36 % negative mentions
The monetization strategies in many games are criticized for being exploitative, featuring microtransactions and pay-to-win elements that disrupt gameplay and diminish player satisfaction. Conversely, some titles are praised for their lack of ads and microtransactions, offering a completely free experience that enhances enjoyment. Overall, the reception of monetization varies significantly, with some players appreciating the absence of financial barriers while others feel that aggressive monetization tactics detract from the gaming experience.
“Well, it's free and there's no microtransactions, so might as well try it out.”
“Muck is a free-to-play game with no microtransactions, which is always a plus in my book.”
“It's completely free and fortunately there is no pay-to-win aspect nor microtransactions of any sort.”
“Furthermore, the game's economic model, including in-game purchases and monetization strategies, often feels exploitative and detracts from the enjoyment of the game.”
“Microtransactions, pay-to-win elements, and other monetization tactics can create an uneven playing field and undermine the sense of achievement and progression.”
“I went into Rogue Company expecting something better and was disappointed and then bombarded with advertising to spend money.”
- character development11 mentions
- 55 % positive mentions
- 18 % neutral mentions
- 27 % negative mentions
Character development in Muck is a mixed bag; while some players appreciate the quirky and cute character designs, others find them lacking in detail and personality. Despite the varied opinions on aesthetics, many reviewers praise the depth of gameplay and mechanics, suggesting that the character development contributes positively to the overall experience. Overall, the game's unique art style and character design evoke strong reactions, but the core gameplay remains highly regarded.
“The character development of Muck Man is just beautiful, 11/10.”
“Excellent game, super complex mechanics and a character development that cannot be better.”
“Character design is equally lackluster, with models that lack detail and personality.”
“At first glance, Muck's quirky art style and endearing character design set the tone for an unconventional journey.”
“The character development of Muck man is just beautiful, 11/10.”
