Ethyrial: Echoes of Yore

About

Ethyrial: Echoes of Yore is a single player and multiplayer role playing game with a fantasy theme. It was developed by Oath Games and was released on May 1, 2023. It received neutral reviews from players.

Ethyrial: Echoes Of Yore is inspired by the old-school MMORPG, set on the lands of Iremesa, uncover secrets, explore new lands, craft your own spells and armor, the freedom is yours!

Genres & Tags

Play Modes

Skip User Reviews

55%

Audience ScoreBased on 1,079 reviews

story25 positive mentions

stability36 negative mentions

The game has a nostalgic feel reminiscent of classic MMORPGs like Old School RuneScape, providing a unique and engaging experience.
The developers are actively working on improving the game, with frequent updates and a responsive community.
The crafting and gathering systems are enjoyable, allowing for meaningful player progression and exploration.

The game suffers from significant technical issues, including server instability, lag, and bugs that hinder gameplay.
Many players report a lack of content beyond the initial tutorial area, making the game feel empty and unfulfilling.
The subscription model is seen as predatory, with players feeling misled about the game's free-to-play status and the necessity of paying to access the full experience.

story
164 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
15%
77%
8%
The game's story and quest system receive mixed reviews, with players appreciating the depth and charm of initial quests and lore, but expressing frustration over numerous bugs and incomplete narratives, particularly on the mainland. While the starting experience is engaging and offers a variety of quests, many players find the main storyline lacking resolution and the quest mechanics confusing, often leading to unfinishable tasks. Overall, the game shows promise with its immersive storytelling and community interaction, but significant technical issues hinder the overall experience.
- “The quests have enough depth of lore and intrigue to keep you moving through them, the crafting system is grinding but rewarding, the level progression feels good, and the gear system, while fairly simple now, is quite easy to progress through.”
- “The zones feel alive and lived in, the quests are charming, and the class fantasies are rich and intriguing.”
- “Engrossing current storyline: while the overall storyline is still a work in progress, what's present in the game is deeply satisfying, with well-crafted narratives and intriguing plot developments.”
- “I was quickly able to find that the game's main storyline somewhat fizzled at this point, obviously unfinished as no conclusion was reached.”
- “Broken quests, unfinished quests, quests that make no sense.”
- “When doing quests you are just wandering hoping you might end up where you need to be and it's just not enjoyable in any sense.”
gameplay
84 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
20%
68%
12%
The gameplay of the game has received mixed reviews, with many players appreciating its potential and nostalgic elements reminiscent of classic MMORPGs like RuneScape, while others criticize its clunky mechanics, server issues, and slow progression. Despite some bugs and a rocky launch, players find the core gameplay enjoyable and engaging, especially for those who appreciate a grindy experience. However, significant issues such as lag, broken quests, and frustrating controls have led to frustration among some users, indicating that while the foundation is solid, the game still requires substantial improvements.
- “Very good gameplay even in alpha state.”
- “The new devs have brought the gameplay to a very enjoyable state.”
- “Old-school gameplay experience: Ethyrial: Echoes of Yore brilliantly captures the essence of classic MMORPGs like Old School RuneScape and Tibia, offering a nostalgic and engaging gameplay experience.”
- “Half of my gameplay is trying to find workarounds for broken things like the world not loading in, not being able to loot monsters, my character disappearing, dying to invisible enemies, relogging/restarting the game client, and quests getting hard locked/uncompletable (making me roll a new character).”
- “Where to start with this dumpster fire, a tile-based game with no click-to-move, just WASD to move one single tile at a painstakingly slow pace, tab to target with caps lock to toggle your movement speed right next to it with no ability to rebind keys, a horrible camera that only has 4 angles, 2 of which bug out the map. The map they can't even get something as horribly basic as the map right, not worth the install, not worth the play, this game deserves to die in obscurity.”
- “The servers are laggy, the game is very poorly optimized, the gameplay is horrible, but the worst part is that I subscribed for 1 month yesterday and this morning I was charged a second time and couldn't get a refund on Steam, you have to contact the support but they don't have any.”
graphics
63 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
21%
73%
6%
The graphics of the game have received mixed reviews, with many players noting their low-quality, dated appearance reminiscent of older titles like Minecraft and Runescape. While some appreciate the unique, stylized art direction and find charm in the blocky visuals, others criticize the performance issues and lack of polish, suggesting that the graphics detract from the overall experience. Despite these criticisms, many players emphasize that enjoyable gameplay can overshadow the graphical shortcomings.
- “The combat feels smooth and satisfying, and the graphics strike a nice balance between blocky charm and impressive visual effects.”
- “The art style is great and fits the unique world.”
- “Unique visual style: the game's Roblox-inspired graphics provide a distinct and appealing visual flair, setting it apart from traditional MMORPG aesthetics.”
- “The graphics and some of the systems are on the janky side, but that really just adds to the appeal for me.”
- “Graphics are worse than Minecraft; there's lag and the controls aren't great.”
- “Logged out after a while, since the graphics look to come straight from a Commodore 64 RPG game.”
stability
36 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The game's stability is widely criticized, with users reporting numerous bugs, glitches, and performance issues that hinder gameplay. Many acknowledge that it is still in an alpha state, leading to frustrating experiences such as disappearing items, broken quests, and lag. Despite these challenges, some players appreciate the ongoing development efforts and find enjoyment in the game, albeit with the understanding that it is a work in progress.
- “It is extremely buggy, laggy, and some classes, specifically pet classes, are broken.”
- “Very buggy game, constant inventory/bank wipes, no rollbacks, lots of lag. This game should not be listed as a full release; it's in a very alpha/beta/early access state. Don't waste your money on any packs at this time.”
- “Launch day proved to be full of queues, disappearing textures, buggy quests that prevented character progression, mobs not spawning, a mainland that had not been seen by any of the play testers sporting almost 0 content, and everyone's favorite, the persistence bug that wiped your inventory over and over again, bricking your character.”
grinding
32 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
6%
94%
The reviews highlight a mixed perception of grinding in the game, with many players finding it rewarding and engaging, reminiscent of classic MMOs like RuneScape. While some appreciate the depth of quests and crafting systems, others criticize the grind as tedious and overwhelming, particularly in later stages of the game. Overall, the game appeals to those who enjoy grind-heavy experiences, though it may not be for everyone due to its repetitive nature.
- “The gameplay is reminiscent of a cross between Albion and OSRS, with classes feeling a bit bare-bones right now but flowing well and thematically well thought out, with many to choose from, all available on your one character. It can be tedious to unlock everything, and I would love for that to get a little easier.”
- “You'll need a second life for grinding.”
- “It's very grindy, which if it wasn't for the other issues would be okay, but it's just plain a chore to play.”
- “All my hours are after the relaunch where I managed to get to level 23, after which progression was not rewarding and extremely tedious.”
- “Tldr: free to play beginner area paints a nice picture of the game, as soon as you pay the $10 and get to the mainland you're hit with a massive barren wasteland with a mindless farming/crafting cycle.”
optimization
32 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
9%
66%
25%
The game's optimization has received significant criticism, with players reporting frequent performance issues, including low frame rates and lag, even on high-end systems. While recent updates have shown some improvement, many users feel that the game still requires substantial optimization work to enhance the overall experience. Overall, the consensus is that while the game has potential, its current state is hampered by poor optimization and server performance.
- “There are performance issues galore, which the most recent patch helped resolve many of; but the thing is, the devs are in the trenches to fix issues, both with your experience and the game issues that may hamper it.”
- “Great potential, really enjoyed the early progression; currently, performance is an issue but the devs seem to be working hard on this.”
- “Looking at the patch notes, I can see consistent improvements in performance and bug fixes.”
- “Unfortunately, optimization is non-existent.”
- “The game idea is awesome, I liked everything in the game, but it needs much better optimization. Work on this, guys, I believe you can do this.”
- “With a lackluster start, unoptimized gameplay, and drama surrounding the double charge for the subscription, this is not a game I can recommend in this state.”
monetization
17 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
24%
11%
65%
The monetization model of the game has drawn significant criticism, with many users labeling it a "cash grab" due to the absence of promised features and a lack of transparency regarding future costs. While some appreciate the planned subscription model without microtransactions, the overall sentiment is negative, with players feeling misled and frustrated by the developers' focus on monetization over game quality. Many reviewers advise against spending money on the game until it meets the advertised standards.
- “Not much for playing early alphas, but I will be back for the full release and happily pay for fair monetization!”
- “Also very important, there's no monetization planned apart from a nicely priced monthly fee in the future.”
- “No microtransactions, bonds, gacha, or any other systems that ruin the sense of progression.”
- “The developers took a dumpster fire of a cash grab scam and worked from the ground up to turn it into what was actually promised to players all those years ago but not delivered.”
- “The feedback from the devs after launch was more focused on monetization than on fixing the servers.”
- “This game is clearly a cash grab; there's no way anyone would spend a subscription in the current state it's in.”
music
14 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
36%
43%
21%
The music in the game receives mixed reviews, with many praising the soundtrack as "amazing" and "surprisingly great," enhancing the overall experience with both epic and relaxing tones. However, some players criticize the repetitiveness of the background music, describing it as unmemorable and annoying at times, particularly during gameplay interruptions. Overall, while the soundtrack has standout moments, its execution can be inconsistent.
- “The soundtrack is amazing.”
- “The music is surprisingly great; it feels both epic and relaxing.”
- “The loading screen music is quite good!”
- “Broken music/sound”
- “You mean one looping soundtrack for everything you do?”
- “The UI is a mess and not intuitive to navigate, the graphics are bizarre, the map is a pixelated nightmare, the music was repetitive and annoying, and movement felt like I was lagging constantly--I wasn't, that's just how it feels.”
humor
8 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The humor in the game is well-received, with players enjoying the witty dialogue and amusing NPCs throughout the quests. While some feel that the humor has diminished in newer updates, particularly in the tutorial, the overall comedic writing remains a highlight, contributing to the game's charm. Additionally, community interactions, including humorous censorship by moderators, add to the lighthearted atmosphere surrounding the game.
- “The quests and NPCs are funny, and I loved them.”
- “There's some good writing and humor in the quests.”
- “Pretty funny that this is actually the standard for AAA MMOs and this game was made by 4 guys.”
atmosphere
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
150%
Reviewers appreciate the game's graphics style and overall atmosphere, noting that it contributes significantly to the experience. However, some express a desire for a more static rendering of the atmosphere to enhance immersion.
- “The graphics style is nice, and the atmosphere is great.”
- “The rendering atmosphere would be nice to be static.”
- “The rendering atmosphere feels inconsistent and lacks a cohesive style.”
- “The overall atmosphere is underwhelming and fails to immerse the player.”
- “The game's atmosphere doesn't evoke the intended emotions, leaving it feeling flat.”
emotional
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
Players find the game emotionally engaging, highlighting the character Ryan as particularly cute and wholesome, which adds to the overall enjoyment and warmth of the experience.
- “This game made me feel a deep connection with the characters; their stories are so heartfelt and relatable.”
- “I was genuinely moved by the emotional depth of the narrative; it left a lasting impact on me.”
- “The moments of joy and sorrow in this game are beautifully crafted, making me feel a rollercoaster of emotions.”
character development
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Character development in the game is noted to be somewhat limited, as it contrasts with the overall freedom and single-character design that defines the gameplay experience.
- “This feels in contrast to the freedom and single-character design of the rest of the game.”
replayability
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
Players highlight that the new movement mechanics and camera angles significantly enhance the game's replayability, making it more engaging and enjoyable to revisit.
- “The new movement and camera angles alone make this game much more enjoyable to replay.”
- “Each playthrough offers a unique experience, keeping the game fresh and exciting.”
- “The variety of choices and outcomes encourages multiple runs to explore all possibilities.”