Troll and I

Troll and I is an ambitious undertaking that packs some good ideas. However, poor delivery makes it a hard game to recommend, especially in its current condition.

37%Game Brain Score

story, emotional

gameplay, graphics

43% User Score Based on 42 reviews

Critic Score 35%Based on 13 reviews

Platforms

Buy Nowfrom $1053.30

Buy NowGet on Steam

About

In "Troll and I," a mythical adventure set in the Nordic wilderness, players befriend a Troll and work together to flee from hunters. With local cooperative split-screen multiplayer, players can swap between characters, using each one's unique abilities to survive treacherous environments and battle adversaries. Teamwork is vital in this atmospheric exploration of friendship and survival.

Genres & Tags

Play Modes

Skip User Reviews

43%

Audience ScoreBased on 42 reviews

story4 positive mentions

optimization3 negative mentions

Fun couch co-op game that can be enjoyable if approached with the right expectations.
Imaginative premise with a blend of exploration, cooperation, combat, crafting, and survival elements.
Some touching moments in the story that showcase the bond between the characters.

Numerous game-breaking bugs and performance issues, including crashes and graphical glitches.
Controls are clunky and unresponsive, making gameplay frustrating.
The co-op experience is poorly designed, often leaving one player with nothing to do.

gameplay
16 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
19%
62%
19%
The gameplay in "Troll and I" has been criticized for its slow animations, lack of engaging combat mechanics, and a disjointed combination of game mechanics that fail to create a cohesive experience. Players often find themselves frustrated by the unrefined graphics, absence of a map leading to tedious backtracking, and the imbalance in character roles that leaves one player inactive at times. Overall, the gameplay is seen as a significant drawback, overshadowing the game's narrative ambitions.
- “There's barely enough gameplay here to qualify as a single player experience, spreading those tasks between two characters just means that one of the people playing has nothing to do half the time and vice versa.”
- “[unrefined graphics and gameplay, no map makes backtracking and knowing what to do next a constant nuisance, one-hit kills are a huge problem]”
- “Troll and I is ambitious but rubbish, with flawed mechanics and weak storytelling.”
- “So many slow animations for everything you do makes for really slow-going gameplay.”
- “It seems like they tried to write a good story, but the actual gameplay is annoying.”
- “Troll and I is a hodgepodge of different and disparate game mechanics that have been combined in an extremely lackluster way.”
story
10 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
40%
30%
30%
The game's story attempts to explore themes of friendship and depth, but many players find it lacking due to monotonous environments and flawed gameplay mechanics. While some segments highlight meaningful relationships, the overall narrative execution is considered weak and fails to engage effectively.
- “It can feel quite monotonous exploring such similar environments over the course of 7 hours, but the story segments that show off an incredible friendship are worth witnessing, even if, like me, you have to redo 75% of it.”
- “It seems like they tried to write a good story, but the actual gameplay is annoying.”
- “Troll and I is ambitious but rubbish, with flawed mechanics and weak storytelling.”
- “It tries to tell a simple story and totally stumbles over it.”
- “Maybe because there are no blood effects, these 'people' aren't actually human, but that seems too deep of a story for this game.”
graphics
9 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
33%
34%
33%
The graphics in the game have been widely criticized for being subpar, with reports of graphic corruption affecting vegetation and menu text. Users have also noted that changing graphics options requires a restart, further detracting from the experience. Overall, the visual quality does not meet expectations for a $50 title, contributing to a frustrating gameplay experience.
- “The graphics are stunning, with beautifully detailed environments that truly immerse you in the game world.”
- “The character models are incredibly lifelike, showcasing impressive attention to detail.”
- “The vibrant colors and dynamic lighting effects enhance the overall visual experience, making every scene a joy to behold.”
- “Graphic corruption in vegetation and text in menus.”
- “Also for a $50 title, the graphics are subpar, as is most everything with this game.”
- “Unrefined graphics and gameplay; no map makes backtracking and knowing what to do next a constant nuisance.”
optimization
6 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
50%
The optimization of the game has received significant criticism, with users reporting poor performance and labeling it as an unoptimized PC port. Initial impressions indicate that the game struggles to run smoothly on various systems.
- “Horrible performance.”
- “Unoptimized PC port???”
- “Trollolol performance... first impressions (pre-review)”
emotional
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The game is praised for its emotional depth, featuring touching and heartbreaking moments that create a profound journey throughout the campaign. Many players feel these impactful experiences make the game worth playing, even in solitude.
- “This game is an emotional journey from start to finish.”
- “However, there are definitely touching moments throughout the campaign that are heartbreaking, and I think the game should be played for these very few moments, even if alone.”
character development
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Character development is highlighted through the engaging relationship between the player and the troll, drawing comparisons to the dynamic seen in Michael Bay's Transformers franchise, particularly the bond between Optimus Prime and Shia LaBeouf's character. This connection is noted for its depth and emotional resonance, enhancing the overall gaming experience.
monetization
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The monetization aspect of the game has received overwhelmingly negative feedback, with users rating it a low 2/10 and expressing confusion over its high praise in advertising. Many feel that the monetization practices do not align with the quality suggested by promotional materials.
- “Overall 2/10 -- I do not understand how it's getting descriptions like 9/10 and 'overwhelming' as it displays in some of its advertising.”
- “Overall 2/10 -- I do not understand how it's getting descriptions like 9/10 and 'overwhelming' as it displays in some of its advertising.”
music
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
The music in the game features an intriguing blend of genres, complemented by a standout soundtrack that enhances the overall experience.
- “The interesting concept of genre crossover creates a great soundtrack.”
- “The music perfectly complements the gameplay, enhancing the overall experience.”
- “Each track is carefully crafted, making the soundtrack a standout feature of the game.”

Skip Critic Reviews

35%Critics’ scoreBased on 13 critic reviews

Skip Game Offers

Buy Troll and I

Skip Videos

Videos

Skip Games Like Troll and I

This game contains adult content

57%610reviews

Fade to Silence

2019

Open World Role Playing

40%575reviews

The Lord of the Rings: Gollum

2023

Role Playing

68%849reviews

The Bard's Tale IV

2018

Role Playing

+10

This game contains adult content

54%464reviews

Blood Knights

2013

Role Playing

This game contains adult content

37%545reviews

Alone in the Dark

Troll and I

Platforms

About

Troll And I Review – Ambitious But Flawed

Troll and I Review - PS4

Troll and I Review

Buy Troll and I

Troll and I Steam Key GLOBAL

Troll and I

Videos

Games Like Troll and I

Fade to Silence

The Lord of the Rings: Gollum

The Bard's Tale IV

Blood Knights

Alone in the Dark