Roguebook

The graphics of the game are widely praised for their vibrant, hand-drawn art style that complements its storybook theme, with many reviewers noting the charming and polished visuals. While the artwork is considered beautiful and engaging, some players have reported minor graphical bugs and performance issues, such as longer load times and occasional crashes. Overall, the aesthetic is seen as a strong point of the game, enhancing the overall experience despite some technical shortcomings.

The game's replayability is a mixed bag, with many players noting its strategic depth and variety of character combinations that enhance replay value. However, comparisons to titles like "Slay the Spire" reveal that it may not reach the same level of infinite replayability, with some players expressing concerns about repetitiveness and limited content. Overall, while there is significant potential for replayability, especially with future updates and character additions, some players feel it currently lacks the depth and variety needed for long-term engagement.

The game's story is generally viewed as minimalistic and lacking depth, with many reviewers noting that it feels unfinished or underdeveloped. While the charming art style and whimsical theme are appreciated, the narrative often takes a backseat to gameplay, resulting in a simplistic backdrop that doesn't significantly enhance the experience. Overall, players express a desire for more substantial storytelling and worldbuilding, despite enjoying the core mechanics and aesthetics of the game.

The music in the game receives mixed reviews, with some players praising its orchestral quality and immersive atmosphere, while others find it generic, forgettable, or repetitive. Many appreciate the overall sound design and how it complements the gameplay, but there are notable criticisms regarding its lack of distinctiveness compared to other titles. Overall, while some players rate the music highly, others consider it a weak point in an otherwise engaging game.

The grinding aspect of the game has received mixed reviews, with many players finding it tedious and unoriginal, often feeling that progression is artificially stretched through excessive grinding. While some players appreciate the aesthetic and initial gameplay, they criticize the slow and frustrating meta-progression system that requires numerous runs to unlock essential features. Overall, the consensus suggests that the grind can detract from the enjoyment, making the game feel more like a chore than a rewarding experience.

The game is widely criticized for its significant stability issues, including frequent crashes, UI glitches, and soft-locks, making it difficult to recommend despite its enjoyable gameplay. While some players acknowledge ongoing updates aimed at fixing these bugs, many express frustration over the game's unfinished state, likening it to a buggy early access title. Overall, the consensus is that while the game has potential, its current stability problems detract heavily from the experience.

The game's optimization has received largely negative feedback, with many users reporting issues such as high VRAM usage, stuttering, freezing, and crashes. While some players find the gameplay enjoyable, they express frustration over the performance, particularly on lower-spec systems, and hope for future updates to improve stability and speed options. Overall, the game is seen as needing significant optimization to enhance the player experience.

The atmosphere of Roguebook is widely praised for its compelling and whimsical storybook-like quality, enhanced by excellent art, animations, and sound design. Reviewers note that while the visuals and music contribute significantly to the game's charm, this atmosphere does not translate into the gameplay experience. Overall, the game's aesthetic elements effectively create an engaging and immersive environment.

The humor in the game is widely praised, with players highlighting its funny interactions and light-hearted style. Many find the comedic elements refreshing, especially in contrast to other games that require excessive clicking to exit. Overall, the humor contributes significantly to the game's enjoyable atmosphere and world-building.

The monetization strategy of the game has been widely criticized, with many players labeling the downloadable content (DLC) as low-effort cash grabs that undermine the game's reputation. Concerns have been raised about the prioritization of monetization over quality, leading to fears that the game may follow the same path as its predecessor, which failed due to similar issues. Players express a preference for DLC that supports ongoing content development and includes modding support, rather than feeling exploitative.

Character development in the game receives mixed reviews; while some praise the vibrant and charming art design along with appealing character designs, others criticize the animations as stiff and unnatural, leading to a lack of cohesion in character presentation. Overall, the character designs are appreciated for their aesthetic appeal, but the execution in animation detracts from the overall experience.

Players express a strong emotional connection to the game, often experiencing joy to the point of tears, indicating that it evokes powerful and positive feelings.