Railroader
- December 7, 2023
- Giraffe Lab LLC
- 50h median play time
Get on Steam"Railroader is a strategy game that offers both single-player and multiplayer modes, including co-op. Set in transition era Appalachia, the game allows you to manage and run your railroad using vintage steam and diesel locomotives. Your goal is to deliver freight cars and passengers safely to their destinations, while expanding and upgrading your railroad in a player-driven world."
Reviews
- Engaging gameplay that combines railroad management with train operations, providing a sense of purpose and progression.
- High level of detail in locomotives and rolling stock, with customizable features such as whistles and road numbers.
- Active development and community support, with regular updates and responsiveness to player feedback.
- Graphics and scenery are currently sparse and lack detail, with many placeholder assets.
- AI functionality is limited, requiring significant micromanagement for efficient operations.
- Some gameplay mechanics, such as train physics and sound design, need further refinement and improvement.
- gameplay159 mentions
- 32 % positive mentions
- 64 % neutral mentions
- 4 % negative mentions
The gameplay of this early access train simulation game is generally praised for its smooth mechanics, intuitive controls, and engaging core loop that combines management and operational tasks. Players appreciate the attention to detail in the train models and the addictive nature of the gameplay, despite some repetitive elements and the need for further polish in graphics and mechanics. Overall, the game offers a fulfilling experience with a solid foundation, making it enjoyable for both casual and dedicated players.
“The gameplay is smooth and enjoyable.”
“It is very clear a lot of time and effort went into making the gameplay enjoyable.”
“The gameplay loop is very interesting, from operating trains in first person, to managing inputs and outputs for industry and providing passenger services for towns along your railway.”
“Recommended specifically if you like what you've just read, but otherwise beware that it can become very tedious and repetitive in terms of actual gameplay: the track layout is fixed and the contracts by definition always involve the same locations and the same types of jobs every time they come up.”
“The way you unlock the map is great but once you have unlocked the map there is no progression and the gameplay loop is incredibly repetitive.”
“However, running the railroad as one person can be quickly overwhelming, so much so that the core gameplay borderline, if not outright, requires that you play with other people and the current AI system is not a solution especially if you are trying to run more than 3 trains at once as one person.”
- graphics119 mentions
- 33 % positive mentions
- 57 % neutral mentions
- 10 % negative mentions
The graphics of the game receive mixed reviews, with many players appreciating the detailed train models and overall visual appeal, while others criticize the optimization and environmental graphics as lacking polish. Some users note that the game runs well on various systems, but there are calls for improvements in graphical fidelity and performance, especially given its early access status. Overall, while the graphics are considered good by some, they are seen as needing further development to reach their full potential.
“The graphics are wonderful - the environment is absolutely beautiful.”
“The graphics are great, the models look fantastic, and trains run extremely smooth.”
“Graphics are beautiful and the models look great!”
“The only cons I can say is graphically it's a bit dated, and clearly early access.”
“I have a pretty beefy PC setup and it struggles with these so-so graphics at any decent setting, so it's certainly not optimized.”
“The graphics are very simple and the scenery needs a lot of work.”
- optimization36 mentions
- 36 % positive mentions
- 42 % neutral mentions
- 22 % negative mentions
The game's optimization has received mixed reviews, with some players experiencing significant performance issues, including stuttering and low frame rates even on high-end systems. While a few users report smooth gameplay, many emphasize the need for substantial optimization improvements to enhance stability and performance, particularly in multiplayer settings. Overall, while the core gameplay is enjoyable, the current optimization status is a major concern for many players.
“The optimization is good as well; most of my PC hardware is pushing eight years old with a six-year-old GTX 1080, and this runs between 50 and 60 FPS comfortably on max settings.”
“Its highly playable with friends as the servers are stable and so well optimized that at times you forget that this only takes 6GB of space.”
“I have been following Railroader for about 2 years now, and was very happy when it went into early access. I think this is a perfect case for early access as the core gameplay loop is there, the game is very well optimized and runs very well, and honestly is way more fun than I even thought it could be.”
“The game severely needs to be optimized; I have a pretty high-end machine and it really taxes it.”
“Before I can honestly recommend this game, it'll need some significant improvements in performance and stability.”
“My laptop doesn't fare much better with a 10300H i5 /1660Ti 16GB DDR4 2933MHz; it drops below 30fps with constant stuttering and hardly reaches over 50fps at 1080p, even on low settings maxed performance.”
- grinding29 mentions
- 3 % positive mentions
- 14 % neutral mentions
- 83 % negative mentions
The grinding aspect of the game is a mixed bag; while some players appreciate the flexibility to avoid excessive grinding and find enjoyment in the logistics of train management, many others find the gameplay repetitive and tedious, especially in the early and later stages. The need to complete similar tasks and contracts can lead to a significant time investment, making it feel like a grind, particularly for those playing solo. Overall, the game offers potential for fun but may require patience due to its grindy nature.
“The principles are sound and so far not too grindy.”
“The early game could be a little grindy, but because of that flexibility to switch those modes on the fly, you never have to grind to get your big fancy locomotives if you really don't want to.”
“Recommended specifically if you like what you've just read, but otherwise beware that it can become very tedious and repetitive in terms of actual gameplay: the track layout is fixed (although you do have to build up to the full layout by completing some one-time missions) and the contracts by definition always involve the same locations and the same types of jobs every time they come up.”
“This game is very grindy, you run cargo with a system of contracts, and if you do not deliver the cargo on time, your reputation goes down.”
- story29 mentions
- 10 % positive mentions
- 79 % neutral mentions
- 10 % negative mentions
The game's story aspect is a mixed bag, with some players appreciating the inclusion of a narrative that provides progression and goals, while others find it lacking or repetitive. Many users express a desire for a more engaging storyline that enhances the gameplay experience, particularly through missions that contribute to a sense of purpose and development. Overall, those who enjoy a structured narrative alongside simulation elements seem to find the game more enjoyable, while others feel it could benefit from a more dynamic and immersive story.
“I like actually having a story to follow and it's not just individual missions that mean nothing.”
“Great storyline; the missions keep you moving forward and wanting to play.”
“Railroads Online is cool since you get to lay your own track, but without any missions or any progress forward, it feels pointless over time.”
“There is a storyline behind the game and milestones you have to meet before progressing, which allows for people to slow down and actually play.”
“Recommended specifically if you like what you've just read, but otherwise beware that it can become very tedious and repetitive in terms of actual gameplay: the track layout is fixed and the contracts always involve the same locations and the same types of jobs every time they come up.”
- stability19 mentions
- 37 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 63 % negative mentions
Overall, the game's stability is generally praised, with many users reporting smooth performance and minimal crashes, even on lower-end systems. However, some players have noted the presence of bugs and graphical glitches, typical for an early access title, but these issues are often considered minor and not game-breaking. The developers are actively addressing these concerns through regular updates, contributing to a positive gaming experience despite the occasional hiccup.
“Runs great on a lower-end laptop.”
“Obviously the game is still in early access, so there are a few things still missing, but overall it looks great and runs exceptionally smooth for a Unity game.”
“Runs great on my system and can't wait for the finished product once it is done.”
“Always buggy.”
“Sure the game has its fair share of bugs and glitches, some worse than others.”
“Slightly buggy at its current state but still very playable and fun!”
- humor7 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
Players find the humor in the game to be a standout feature, often highlighting unexpected and absurd moments, such as the amusing mechanics of trains moving slowly uphill. The comedic elements, particularly the recurring joke about the "funny choo choo," contribute to a lighthearted multiplayer experience that sets it apart from other titles. Overall, the humor enhances the enjoyment and uniqueness of the game.
“My experiences in multiplayer servers have also been absolutely hilarious at times.”
“It was funny and caught me off guard.”
“Laughing about going 12 miles an hour uphill with 2 locomotives and 1 car is certainly something I can't find in another game.”
- music6 mentions
- 33 % positive mentions
- 17 % neutral mentions
- 50 % negative mentions
The game lacks background music, which some players initially found odd but ultimately appreciated for its calming effect, allowing for a more relaxed pace. However, the absence of engaging music can make the gameplay feel empty, prompting players to seek their own music or videos to enhance the experience. Overall, while the lack of a soundtrack is noted, it can contribute to a more tranquil atmosphere.
“And because there's no rush to expand, you can take the game at your own pace and it's really relaxing, especially with good music.”
“There's no music to get you into the groove while you manage your network, and a lot of the world is still empty or filled with placeholder objects.”
“The game is very slow; definitely something you'll want to have music or a video going alongside.”
“There's no background music, which seemed strange at first, but was kind of nice, actually.”
- emotional3 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
Players express a mix of frustration and admiration regarding the emotional aspect of the game, highlighting that while it is still in early access and requires improvements in landscape and controls, the overall experience is profoundly impactful and evokes strong feelings.
“Look controls make me want to cry.”
- atmosphere3 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The atmosphere of the game is highly praised for its captivating quality, enhanced by a supportive community and dedicated developers. Reviewers note that it effectively blends various gameplay elements with a sense of realistic immersion, contributing to an engaging overall experience.
“This is my first Steam review ever, and it is because I am amazed at the community, the developers, and the entire atmosphere surrounding this game.”
“This is a very good game; its atmosphere can captivate you.”
“This game does a great job of blending operations, problem-solving, planning, business-building, and atmospheric realism.”
- replayability3 mentions
- 67 % positive mentions
- -33 % neutral mentions
- 67 % negative mentions
The game offers high replayability due to its stable base mechanics, numerous goals, and engaging rail missions, providing players with hours of progression and activities to pursue. Users express optimism for the future, highlighting the potential for even more content and improvements.
“At least for what it is now, it's incredibly stable. The base gameplay mechanics are there and there's unlimited replayability.”
“This team has so much potential and yes, the replayability is high. There are goals to work towards, financials to be aware of, and rail missions to fulfill. There's more than enough to keep one occupied while they sort things out and continue to release fixes. The future looks bright in my book for these guys and gals!”
“This team has so much potential and yes, the replayability is high; there are goals to work towards, financials to be aware of, and rail missions to fulfill. Like I said, there's more than enough to keep one occupied now while they sort things out and keep coming out with fixes and such, but man, the future looks bright in my book for these guys and gals!”
“There are hours and hours worth of progression here, and lots of replay value as well.”
- monetization1 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 100 % negative mentions
The monetization aspect of the game is characterized by active developer involvement in server management, alongside a community-driven approach that encourages players to share experiences and promote their own multiplayer servers.
