My Island

The music in the game receives mixed reviews; while some players find it beautiful and relaxing, others feel it does not fit the game's tropical setting and can disrupt the overall mood. Many users appreciate the serene quality of the soundtrack, but there are calls for more variety and originality, as some tracks are perceived as repetitive or reminiscent of other games. Overall, the music enhances the visual experience for some, but leaves others feeling disconnected from the game's atmosphere.

The game's story aspect is largely criticized, with many users noting the absence of a meaningful plot or narrative, which detracts from the overall experience. While some players find enjoyment in the gameplay mechanics and crafting elements, they express hope for future updates that will introduce a storyline, as the game currently feels unfinished and lacks direction. Overall, the consensus is that without a compelling story, the game may struggle to retain player interest in the long term.

The game's optimization has received mixed reviews, with some players reporting significant performance issues that require low settings to achieve recommended performance, while others with higher-end systems experience smooth gameplay at maximum settings. Many users express frustration over glitches and a lack of polish, suggesting that an optimization pass is necessary. Overall, the game may not meet the expectations of those seeking a well-optimized experience.

Players find the grinding aspect of the game to be somewhat mitigated by the ability to craft most items early on, although resource limitations can lead to repetitive island hopping. The introduction of a peaceful mode caters to those more interested in building and farming, while farming itself has been simplified, reducing the grind. Overall, many reviewers appreciate the balance between resource gathering and gameplay enjoyment, noting that the game remains engaging without excessive grinding.

The humor in the game is largely derived from its poor animations and amusing graphical glitches, which players find entertaining rather than frustrating. Character customization options and unexpected in-game events, like an orca attack or a flying raft, add to the comedic experience, making the overall gameplay feel lighthearted and fun. Players appreciate the absurdity of the game's quirks, often laughing at the unintentional humor that arises from its technical issues.

The monetization of the game is heavily criticized, with users labeling it as a blatant cash grab rather than a legitimate gaming experience. Many feel it lacks the quality and development effort expected from a game, comparing it unfavorably to student projects and expressing skepticism about its potential to progress beyond early access.

The game's atmosphere is described as positive and idyllic, providing a refreshing contrast to the often violent and depressing tone of many contemporary games. However, some players feel that the atmosphere may resonate differently based on gender perspectives, as it reflects the developer's feminine touch while still presenting challenges.

Users highlight that the game "Dark and Light" offers high replayability, with some describing it as "infinitely replayable," indicating that players find it engaging enough to return to multiple times.

While the character design in the game is praised for its aesthetic appeal, players feel that the character development lacks depth and requires more engaging activities, such as building and harvesting, to enhance the overall experience.