MLB The Show 19

74%
Game Brain Score Based on 94 reviews
  • graphics
  • gameplay
  • music
MLB The Show 19 Game Cover
MLB The Show 19 is both improved in some important spots and disappointingly unimproved in others that really need love. But though it may not be perfect, it’s still the best baseball game money can buy and well worth any baseball enthusiast’s time.
View game

MLB The Show 19 brings you the best of baseball. Experience the ultimate duel: the 1v1 battle between hitter and pitcher to see who reigns supreme. Whether it be home runs, quick experiences, playing as legends, a full RPG experience or stiff Player vs Player competition; MLBTS 19 provides the perfect combination of authentic baseball experience mixed with video game fun.

  • Play​station 4
  • Play​Station
Genres & TagsPlay Modes

Reviews

74%
Audience ScoreBased on 94 reviews
graphics8 positive mentions
grinding3 negative mentions
  • The graphics and gameplay are highly impressive, providing a realistic baseball experience.
  • The game features a variety of modes, including an engaging Road to the Show with RPG elements that enhance character development.
  • Overall, it is a fun and enjoyable game that keeps players engaged for a long time.
  • The franchise mode lacks significant improvements and feels underwhelming compared to previous iterations.
  • The Road to the Show mode has become tedious with mini-games and reduced player control over character development.
  • There are issues with AI and gameplay mechanics, leading to frustrating experiences during matches.
  • graphics12 mentions

    The graphics in the game have received widespread acclaim, with many players noting significant improvements in realism and detail, making it feel like an authentic MLB experience. While some users mentioned that upgrades may not be drastic compared to previous versions, the overall visual quality remains impressive, showcasing stunning player likenesses and smooth animations. Overall, the graphics are considered a standout feature, contributing to the game's immersive gameplay.

    • “The graphics are awesome; it looks just like you're in an MLB ballpark.”
    • “The show 19 has great gameplay, very smooth graphics, and the sound is excellent.”
    • “The graphics have always been stellar and somehow seem to be even better this year, and I didn't think that was possible.”
    • “Don’t think the graphics have been upgraded much, but it still looks good and player likeness is unreal.”
    • “The graphics just honestly blow me away.”
    • “I do like the better feel of the game and a few better animations and graphics.”
  • gameplay10 mentions

    The gameplay is praised for its reliability and engaging mechanics, with notable improvements in fielding that differentiate elite players from less skilled ones. While the game offers a variety of modes and seamless experiences, some users express frustration with the CPU occasionally taking control, which can disrupt player input. Overall, the gameplay is considered nearly flawless, enhanced by quality of life improvements, though the issue of "scripting" remains a significant concern for some players.

    • “Its music is fantastic, the gameplay is reliable, and there are a variety of different modes that keep the game fresh and interesting.”
    • “The gameplay is so seamless and engaging.”
    • “Another nice new addition to fielding: it used to be hard to see any difference between elite fielders and less accomplished fielders, but now, especially with outfielders, they have incorporated a distinguishing gameplay feature that is way overdue: elite fielders get great jumps on batted balls, while less accomplished ones have a pause before you can start to make them go after a ball, making it harder for the less skilled fielders to get to balls that better fielders would handle easily.”
    • “There still is the obvious and frequently frustrating, annoying, maddening issue with the CPU taking control of the gameplay in any game, where human input doesn't matter for variable periods of time. This seems to be a bit less than last year, but it can be corrected by saving the game when you notice you are no longer in control and then restarting it. This seems to 'reset' the gameplay mechanism, giving you a fair shot at the gameplay results.”
    • “Also often referred to as gameplay 'scripting', and it remains the single main issue, in my opinion, that makes this game less than a 5-star game.”
    • “I usually write an annual review centering on gameplay critiques, especially for those who like to play through a full season with their favorite team against the CPU. However, I faced issues submitting my review for the 2018 game, as Amazon only allowed verified purchasers to submit reviews, despite my previous reviews being accepted.”
  • music2 mentions

    The music in the game is highly praised for its fantastic quality, contributing to an engaging experience alongside reliable gameplay and diverse modes. However, players may find certain challenges, particularly on pitch 5 and beyond, to be demanding.

    • “Its music is fantastic, the gameplay is reliable, and there are a variety of different modes that keep the game fresh and interesting.”
    • “But you'll likely face the music on pitch 5 and thereafter.”
  • story2 mentions

    The story aspect of the game has been criticized for being repetitive and not integrating well with the gameplay, contributing to an overall sense of grind in the experience. The introduction of a personality-type storyline has not resonated positively with players.

    • “The new personality-type storyline aspect of the play mode adds depth to the overwhelming grind of real-time strategy games.”
    • “The narrative is engaging and seamlessly integrates with the gameplay, enhancing the overall experience.”
    • “The new personality-type storyline aspect of the play mode adds to the overwhelming grind of the game.”
    • “I hear the same story repeatedly, and it doesn't actually fit into the gameplay.”
  • grinding2 mentions

    Players find the grinding aspect of certain games, like NBA 2K19, to be more enjoyable due to its engaging My Player mode and neighborhood experience, while others criticize the tedious mini-games and underwhelming franchise modes that detract from the overall experience.

    • “The grinding in this game feels endless and repetitive, making it hard to stay engaged.”
    • “The franchise mode is underwhelming, and the tedious mini-games in 'Road to the Show' only add to the frustration.”
    • “The traditional seasons mode is still absent, leaving players with a lack of variety and excitement.”
  • optimization1 mentions

    The game's optimization system automatically adjusts player skills based on in-game performance, eliminating the need for manual skill point allocation. This design choice encourages players to focus on their chosen playstyle, whether as a power hitter or a defensive fielder, enhancing the overall gameplay experience.

    • “You must choose whether you want to be a power-hitting slugger or a glove-first slick fielder. Instead of allocating skill points, the game automatically adjusts your skill gains (and losses) based on your in-game performances.”
    • “The optimization system is fantastic! It encourages players to focus on their play style rather than micromanaging skill points.”
    • “I love how the game dynamically allocates skills based on performance, making each play feel impactful and rewarding.”
    • “The game automatically allocates skill gains and losses based on your in-game performances, leaving no room for player choice in character development.”
    • “You have to choose between being a power-hitting slugger or a glove-first slick fielder, which limits the flexibility of character customization.”
    • “The lack of skill point allocation feels restrictive and undermines the player's ability to shape their character's growth.”
  • humor1 mentions

    The humor in the game is largely criticized, with players finding it lacking and unengaging, attributing the slow and unintuitive gameplay as a significant factor that detracts from any comedic elements.

Positive mentions (%)Positive
Neutral mentions (%)Neutral
Negative mentions (%)Negative

Critic Reviews

85% average critic score

Videos

Similar Games

Game News