MLB 15: The Show

84%
Game Brain Score Based on 112 reviews
  • graphics
  • gameplay
  • music
MLB 15: The Show Game Cover
MLB 15 confidently eschews splashy new features in favor of refinement

With the addition of General Manager Contracts, you now must consider Ownership Expectations when operating your team, and your performance will determine the job offers that you'll be confronted with. Building a championship-caliber team is more dynamic than in previous iterations, with the new Performance-based Player Progression, as well as improved Trade and Contract logic. Partner up with Bra…

  • Play​station 4
  • Play​station 5
  • Play​Station
Genres & TagsPlay Modes

Reviews

84%
Audience ScoreBased on 112 reviews
graphics16 positive mentions
music3 negative mentions
  • The game features stunning graphics and realistic player animations, enhancing the overall visual experience.
  • Gameplay mechanics, including pitching and batting, have been improved, making for a more engaging and enjoyable experience.
  • The customization options for players and the various game modes, such as Road to the Show and Franchise, provide a lot of replayability and fun for players.
  • Some players have reported frustrating AI behavior, particularly in fielding and baserunning, which can detract from the overall gameplay experience.
  • The online multiplayer experience has been criticized for lag and issues with matchmaking, making it less enjoyable for competitive players.
  • Many reviewers feel that the game does not offer enough new features compared to previous iterations, making it feel more like a roster update than a significant upgrade.
  • graphics36 mentions

    The graphics in the game show noticeable improvements over previous versions, particularly in stadium visuals and player animations, contributing to a more immersive experience. While some users feel that certain textures, like skin, still need enhancement for greater realism, the overall graphical quality is praised as solid and engaging, with dynamic interactions adding to the visual appeal. However, there are mixed opinions on whether the graphics alone can sustain long-term interest in the gameplay.

    • “Graphics are upgraded from last year, and last year was pretty great to begin with.”
    • “Great game though: really nice graphics, especially the stadiums.”
    • “[gorgeous visuals, real-life strategy, intense pitcher-hitter battles, best crowds ever]”
    • “First off, let me say that I personally think that 98% of next/current gen games underperform when it comes to graphics, and although this game is obviously better than its PS3 counterpart, I do believe the graphics could be more realistic. Texture, especially skin texture, is still a big area that needs to be worked on.”
    • “The graphics are average, but the animations are great.”
    • “I think they need to just keep improving the stadium's graphics and their surroundings.”
  • gameplay17 mentions

    Overall, the gameplay is praised for its smooth mechanics, realistic pitching and batting systems, and engaging player interactions, making it easy to learn and enjoyable for fans. However, some users noted minor bugs and a tendency for the game to become repetitive over time. The graphics complement the gameplay well, enhancing the overall experience, though some aspects may feel underwhelming compared to the game's potential.

    • “The mechanics and movement of the players is better than I have seen in an MLB game.”
    • “The pitching mechanics are phenomenal, and the batting is kept simple.”
    • “It's the under-the-hood gameplay improvements and additions that really make the difference; engaging in mental battles with base runners, pitchers, and even outfielders is a big part of the experience this time out.”
    • “This makes for crappy gameplay and basically nullifies all of the other really cool aspects of this game.”
    • “Horrorshow defensive mechanics.”
    • “Great game, good gameplay, little buggy at times, but nothing major.”
  • music4 mentions

    The music in the game is limited to the pre-existing tracks, which some players find repetitive after extended playtime. Users express a desire for the ability to import their own MP3s to enhance the listening experience.

    • “My one criticism: you cannot store MP3s on your PS4 to import into the game, so you are limited to just the music that comes with the game.”
    • “The music gets repetitive after hours and hours of gameplay.”
    • “PS4 really needs to allow you to import your own soundtrack.”
  • replayability1 mentions

    Reviewers highlight the game's exceptionally high replayability, emphasizing that it significantly contributes to its overall entertainment value and aligns with the core purpose of gaming.

    • “This game truly is entertaining, and the replayability is extremely high. In the end, isn't that the whole point of a game?”
    • “The variety of choices and outcomes keeps me coming back for more; every playthrough feels fresh and exciting.”
    • “With multiple paths and endings, I find myself diving back in to explore every possibility.”
  • stability1 mentions

    Overall, the game is generally stable with only minor bugs reported, which do not significantly impact the gameplay experience.

    • “The game crashes frequently, making it nearly unplayable at times.”
    • “I experienced constant lag and frame drops, which ruined the overall experience.”
    • “There are numerous bugs that disrupt gameplay, leading to frustrating moments.”
  • atmosphere1 mentions

    The atmosphere in the game is highly immersive, featuring incredibly detailed player models and stadiums that replicate the essence of baseball. The engaging "Road to the Show" mode, combined with the nuanced crowd dynamics and noise, enhances the overall experience, making players feel truly part of the game.

    • “The incredibly detailed player models and stadiums create a highly immersive baseball atmosphere.”
    • “The highly-detailed crowd replicates the true essence of a baseball game, enhancing the overall experience.”
    • “Little things like crowd noise significantly affect play on the field, adding to the game's atmosphere.”
  • monetization1 mentions

    The monetization in the game features microtransactions, particularly in the Diamond Dynasty mode, which have not significantly changed from the previous year on the Vita platform. Additionally, users have noted that load times remain a concern.

    • “The load times and microtransactions in Diamond Dynasty are not much different from last year on Vita.”
    • “The monetization strategy feels overly aggressive, making it hard to enjoy the game without spending extra money.”
    • “I feel like I'm constantly being pushed to spend more on in-game purchases, which ruins the overall experience.”
Positive mentions (%)Positive
Neutral mentions (%)Neutral
Negative mentions (%)Negative

Critic Reviews

82% average critic score

Videos

Similar Games