Idle Clans

About

Idle Clans - MMORPG is a single player casual simulation game. It received positive reviews from players.

Idle Clans - MMORPG is a single-player simulation game that offers a simplified and casual take on the traditional MMORPG experience. It involves significant grinding and progression through managing your clan and resources. The game typically takes around 15 hours to complete, providing an engaging yet laid-back gameplay experience.

Genres & Tags

Play Modes

Single-Player

Skip User Reviews

81%

Audience ScoreBased on 474 reviews

gameplay5 positive mentions

monetization8 negative mentions

The game offers a fun and engaging idle experience with a player-driven economy and no forced ads.
Players can earn premium features through in-game currency, making it accessible without spending real money.
The community is active and supportive, enhancing the multiplayer experience and making it enjoyable to play with friends.

Many core features and skills are locked behind a paywall, which can frustrate players who prefer a fully free experience.
The game suffers from bugs and performance issues, including freezing and login problems, which detract from the overall enjoyment.
The user interface can be difficult to navigate, especially on mobile devices, making it hard to read and interact with the game.

monetization
16 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
25%
25%
50%
The monetization model of the game is generally well-received, with no forced ads and optional microtransactions that are not required for gameplay. Players appreciate the ability to earn in-game currency for purchases, though some skills are locked behind a paywall, and there are mixed opinions on the value of the paid content. Overall, the game allows for a free-to-play experience while offering support options for those who choose to spend money.
- “This game has no ads.”
- “All in-app monetization is one-time pay and can be purchased with in-game acquired currency through the player market as well.”
- “Fantastic game and community, entertaining for short and long periods, can be played entirely for free, in-app purchases are just developer support (which is good).”
- “There are microtransactions, of course, but they are not required. However, their prices are pretty high for what little you get out of it, and some of the skills are locked behind a paywall like in old school RuneScape.”
- “Pathic cash grab; can't farm without paying cash.”
- “If you love grindfest idlers with more refined monetization and progression models that allow for less whales, as well as having one large server with IM, GIM, and regular players together - check this game out.”
grinding
16 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The game is characterized as highly grindy, appealing to fans of idle games with a variety of activities such as combat, farming, and crafting. While it offers a casual and addictive experience, some players find the reward system lacking and note that certain key gameplay elements are locked behind a paywall. Overall, it provides a mix of mindless fun and extensive grinding opportunities, suitable for both solo and group play.
- “Extremely grindy game with a poor reward system.”
- “Could have been a great game but after the tutorial, I saw literally some of the key gameplay is locked like farming, etc. because you need to pay real money for that.”
- “Decent game, becomes quite grindy.”
gameplay
15 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
33%
47%
20%
The gameplay is generally engaging and features well-designed mechanics that keep players returning, but many users express frustration over core skills and activities being locked behind a paywall, which detracts from the overall experience. While some players find the gameplay simple yet enjoyable, the lack of substantial content without payment and the absence of a compelling storyline lead to boredom after a short period. Overall, the game shows potential but is hindered by its monetization strategy.
- “The gameplay is engaging, with well-designed mechanics that keep you coming back.”
- “Great gameplay and welcoming community.”
- “Awesome game and mechanics!”
- “A lack of storylines is also apparent after a few days of gameplay.”
- “Boring, extremely boring after 1 or 2 hours of gameplay, and you need $9.99 to unlock the full game; otherwise, some skills are locked behind a paywall subscription-based model.”
- “Could have been a great game, but after the tutorial, I saw literally some of the key gameplay is locked, like farming, because you need to pay real money for that.”
story
11 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
18%
55%
27%
The game's story aspect is criticized for its lack of depth, with players noting a repetitive nature in quests, particularly the frequent "godslayer" tasks. While the initial gameplay can feel overwhelming, players find enjoyment in cooperative clan activities and the simplicity of following quests. Suggestions for improvement include the introduction of procedural generation for more varied text-based quests or dungeons.
- “The first few hours were a bit overwhelming, I will be honest, but I started just following the quests and everything came easily right after.”
- “Guys, if you've played Melvor Idle and wished you weren't in a single-player idle quest, then this is your dream come true.”
- “A lack of storylines is also apparent after a few days of gameplay.”
- “It also freezes every time I try to open the quest tab.”
- “Yeah, it takes a while to unlock and you can't brew potions without the farming skill, but you can just reroll the quest and do something else until you unlock it.”
stability
5 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The game's stability is a significant issue, with frequent freezing reported during gameplay, particularly when accessing the quest tab. Players experience interruptions that prevent progression, leading to frustration despite the game's potential. Overall, the current state is described as buggy and in need of urgent fixes.
- “Game would be fantastic, but it keeps freezing. I've only loaded the game twice for over 20 minutes and I've only made it to level 2. The game acts like it's running but freezes; the duration bar keeps running normally, you can flip between tabs, but no XP, no extra items, meaning quantity hits a number and then stops. You cannot click another item or anything.”
- “With this current patch, my game freezes frequently.”
- “It also freezes every time I try to open the quest tab.”
optimization
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The game is reported to be well-optimized for both tablets and computers, ensuring a smooth performance across these platforms.
- “It seems like this game was optimized for tablets and computers.”
- “The performance on lower-end devices is disappointing, making it nearly unplayable.”
- “I encountered frequent frame drops and long loading times, indicating poor optimization.”
graphics
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
33%
100%
The graphics of the game are described as simple yet nice, with ongoing improvements noted by users. However, some players feel that the lack of visual appeal detracts from the overall experience, particularly in relation to gameplay mechanics like idle time.
- “Simple systems, nice graphics that are currently being improved, good community.”
- “If it had like 72 hours of idle time, maybe it would be playable as an incremental game. I tried to like this game multiple times, but for something with zero graphics, one day of idle is just not enough.”
- “The graphics are so outdated that it feels like I'm playing a game from a decade ago.”
- “The visual quality is disappointing; the textures are bland and lack detail, making the game feel lifeless.”
atmosphere
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The atmosphere is characterized by a strong sense of collaboration, with players enjoying a cooperative environment that encourages time management and clan development. Users appreciate the variety of activities available, enhancing the overall experience.
- “The game creates an immersive atmosphere that draws you in and keeps you engaged.”
- “The stunning visuals and sound design contribute to a captivating atmosphere that enhances the overall experience.”
- “The co-op atmosphere fosters teamwork and camaraderie, making every moment feel meaningful.”
music
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
50%
The music aspect of the game has received mixed feedback, with users praising the overall brilliance of the game but expressing a strong desire for more background music throughout. They also suggest including an option to toggle the music for players who prefer a quieter experience.
- “Brilliant game but really needs background music for everything with the option to toggle it for people who don't want music.”
replayability
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Users express a desire for greater replayability, comparing the game unfavorably to titles like RuneScape and Melver Idle, which offer more engaging content for repeated play. This suggests that the current game may lack sufficient incentives for players to return after their initial experience.
- “I wouldn't mind spending good money if it had more replay value like RuneScape or Melvor Idle.”