Idle Clans

About

Idle Clans is a single player and multiplayer casual role playing game. It was developed by Isam Games and was released on April 7, 2023. It received mostly positive reviews from players.

Idle Clans is a multiplayer idle game that combines the classic MMORPG experience with simplified gameplay and less time commitment. Features include a player-driven economy, PvE, trading, quests, crafting and opportunities to play, socialize and collaborate with other players.

Genres & Tags

Play Modes

Skip User Reviews

74%

Audience ScoreBased on 958 reviews

gameplay22 positive mentions

grinding51 negative mentions

Engaging multiplayer features with clan systems that enhance the gameplay experience.
Ability to earn premium membership through in-game currency, making it accessible for free-to-play players.
Active development with regular updates and a responsive developer who listens to community feedback.

Significant portions of the game are locked behind a paywall, which can hinder progression for free-to-play players.
User experience issues, including a clunky interface and frequent server connection problems.
Repetitive gameplay with limited activities available at any given time, leading to a lack of depth.

gameplay
59 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
37%
56%
7%
The gameplay of "Idle Clans" is characterized by a blend of idle and active mechanics, offering a casual experience that can be enjoyed in short bursts or longer sessions. While the game features engaging clan dynamics and cooperative elements, many players criticize its repetitive nature, lack of depth, and significant paywalls that restrict access to core gameplay features. Overall, it presents a fun yet simplistic idle experience, though it may not satisfy those seeking more complex gameplay.
- “This is a great idle game with a breadth of active and AFK mechanics without being overly complicated.”
- “Progress feels consistent, and mechanics are engaging without being overwhelming.”
- “With its accessible gameplay, charming graphics, and strategic elements, the game offers a rewarding experience that can be savored in short bursts or over more extended play sessions.”
- “The gameplay itself is very bare-bones with little depth or creativity.”
- “Extremely repetitive and boring gameplay loop.”
- “Monotonous gameplay, lack of variety and lack of depth make the game boring after the first minutes.”
grinding
51 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The grinding aspect of the game is a mixed bag, with players noting that while it can be tedious and time-consuming, it also fosters a sense of community and progression. Many players appreciate the ability to earn premium items through grinding, although some skills are locked behind a paywall, making it challenging for free-to-play users. Overall, the game is described as a fun, idle experience that rewards patience and dedication, but it can feel overly grindy at times, especially for those looking to access all features without spending money.
- “I spent so much time grinding the singular creature that drops green leather (tier 3 leather), a mob that I was already vastly overleveled for. By the time I had gotten the 6 pieces needed to make myself a set of armor, I had already outleveled the gear and needed red leather (tier 4).”
- “While it's grindy, it gathered a lot of great people and is perfect to just leave in the background or chat with people.”
- “Farming, enchanting, and several other skills are behind a 'premium membership' paywall, which largely renders the game inaccessible to free-to-play players.”
monetization
43 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
7%
37%
56%
The monetization in the game is generally viewed as non-predatory, with most microtransactions being cosmetic or related to quality-of-life improvements, and no forced ads. However, some players feel that the monetization model is restrictive, with high costs for inventory slots and a perception of cash-grabbing tactics, particularly regarding the inclusion of ads and paywalls for certain features. Overall, while the game offers a fair balance for free-to-play players, there are criticisms about its reliance on microtransactions and ads, which can detract from the overall experience.
- “No over the top monetization.”
- “Most non-predatory monetization I've ever seen!”
- “Overall, the game strikes a fair balance between free-to-play accessibility and monetization.”
- “I feel the game is held back by its monetization, and inventory slots get too expensive.”
- “Sorry to say, but this early access is rather boring and seems to be a cash grab.”
- “Some of the biggest cons on this is the inclusion of ads and a pay wall for 3 skills, one of which basically was the whole economy for the play test. Having that locked up means free to play on this game is slow and boring beyond belief.”
graphics
23 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
13%
74%
13%
The graphics of the game receive mixed reviews, with some players appreciating the charming and colorful art style that suits its casual nature, while others criticize the visuals as simplistic or reminiscent of older games. Although the graphics may not be groundbreaking, they are considered adequate for the gameplay experience, with some users noting a sense of progression and appeal compared to similar titles. Overall, while the visuals enhance the game for some, they fall short for others who expect more from modern graphics.
- “Idle Clans boasts charming and colorful graphics that are pleasing to the eye.”
- “While the visuals may not be groundbreaking, they perfectly suit the game's light-hearted and casual nature.”
- “Its intricate clan management system, stunning visuals, and balanced gameplay redefine the genre.”
- “Even the graphics are lazy stock images.”
- “However, its repetitive gameplay and lackluster graphics pale in comparison to genre titans like Adventure Capitalist.”
- “Game mechanics from the 1990s and graphics from the 80s.”
story
16 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
19%
62%
19%
The game's story is primarily driven by engaging daily and weekly quests that provide a sense of direction and purpose, reminiscent of other idle games like Melvor Idle. However, players express frustration over the heavy reliance on premium features and paywalls, which can hinder progress and create a grind-heavy experience. While the quest mechanics are enjoyable, the overall narrative and resource economy feel limited and stale, impacting long-term engagement.
- “Drawing comparisons to other idle games, Idle Clans excels in its engaging mechanics and unique storytelling, however, it lacks in graphical quality and overall atmosphere.”
- “The daily and weekly quests shake things up and make the game really fun.”
- “Still enjoying the game, even as I get to the highest tiers in many skills; the addition of the extermination skill and daily/weekly quests keeps this goal-driven.”
- “Very slow, with items and skills you need to finish quests locked off behind a paywall.”
- “Some daily quests are stuck behind the need for premium, which is $9.99.”
- “Even the daily quests force you to do things locked behind premium, so you are just always falling behind.”
music
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
25%
25%
50%
The reviews indicate a notable absence of music and sound effects in the game, with some players expressing disappointment over this lack. While some users do not view it as a major issue, there is anticipation for a future music update that could enhance the overall experience.
- “I'm excited for the music update! I started by playing this on my phone, and now it's installed on the PC too for when things get serious.”
- “I see a lot of complaints about music or sounds missing from the game; it doesn't really seem like a huge deal to me.”
- “No music?”
humor
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The humor in the game is characterized by its absurdity, as players find themselves laughing at the unexpected consequences of in-game actions, such as account bans. However, the overall comedic experience is undermined by a shallow gameplay experience and an unbalanced economy, leading to a mix of amusement and disappointment.
- “I just started laughing and asked if they were going to ban other accounts that traded and had any contact with my account, so they banned two of my other accounts and logged off.”
- “Tl;dr, promises a lot but is disappointingly shallow and comes with a hilariously unbalanced economy.”
atmosphere
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
150%
50%
The atmosphere of Idle Clans is characterized by a vibrant and engaging interface that enhances team-oriented gameplay through various events and raids. However, some users feel that the game's graphical quality falls short, detracting from the overall immersive experience.
- “The atmosphere in the game is incredible, with a vibrant clan interface that fosters teamwork through fun early and late-game events and raids.”
- “The immersive atmosphere really draws you in, making every moment feel engaging and exciting.”
- “The game's atmosphere is enhanced by its stunning visuals and sound design, creating a truly captivating experience.”
- “Drawing comparisons to other idle games, Idle Clans excels in its engaging mechanics and unique storytelling; however, it lacks in graphical quality and overall atmosphere.”
optimization
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The game's optimization has been criticized for causing overheating issues, significantly impacting performance. While the clan mechanism provides performance buffs, players find themselves grinding for minimal gains after quickly maxing out available enhancements.
- “The game is so badly optimized that it is literally overheating.”
- “The clan mechanism also offers performance buffs to its members, but our clan quickly maxed out the available buffs, and 'team effort' is now basically grinding materials required for the last, costly percentage gains offered.”
stability
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The game's stability has been criticized for being buggy, with users reporting significant rollbacks, various glitches, and intrusive pop-ups. Additionally, some features are inaccessible unless played on mobile, and a considerable portion of the game is locked behind a paywall.
- “It is a little buggy sometimes.”
- “So far, I experienced huge rollbacks, several glitches, and a bunch of annoying pop-ups. Additionally, I can't access certain features because I'm not playing on mobile, and half of the game is locked behind a paywall.”
replayability
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
The game has been criticized for its lack of replayability, with users indicating that once completed, there is little incentive to play through it again.
- “The game lacks any meaningful choices, making replayability virtually nonexistent.”
- “Once you've completed the story, there's little incentive to play again.”
- “The gameplay feels repetitive, and I found myself losing interest after the first playthrough.”
character development
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
Reviewers praise the distinct character designs and high-quality animations, which enhance the overall enjoyment of the gameplay experience.
- “The character designs are distinct, and the animations are well-done, adding an extra layer of enjoyment to the gameplay experience.”
- “The depth of character backstories really enhances the emotional connection I feel while playing.”
- “I love how the characters evolve throughout the game, making each decision feel impactful and meaningful.”