Detective Pikachu Returns is a half-decent sequel to a flawed original; it may be a great experience for younger children who love Pokémon, but weak puzzles and lackluster dialogue will disengage the rest of us.
"Detective Pikachu Returns" is a single-player Adventure game with a good story that takes about 10 hours to beat. As Tim Goodman, you team up with a coffee-loving, self-assured Pikachu to solve mysteries in Ryme City, a place where Pokémon and people coexist. Together, you investigate incidents and gather clues with the help of various Pokémon, unraveling a series of intriguing cases in this cinematic adventure game. The lovable yet tough-talking Pikachu keeps his charm while proving his detective skills.
The game features a charming story and lovable characters, making it enjoyable for fans of the franchise.
Great for younger players, with simple controls and a relaxing gameplay experience.
Many players appreciated the nostalgic feel reminiscent of old-school graphic adventure games.
The gameplay is often criticized for being too simplistic and lacking challenge, especially for older players.
Some players found the graphics and presentation to be disappointing compared to the previous installment.
There are complaints about excessive dialogue and cutscenes, leading to a feeling of boredom during gameplay.
story
5 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
60%
40%
The story of the game is engaging, particularly for fans of the first Detective Pikachu, as it delves deeper into the quest to find Tim's dad and features a variety of Pokémon from different regions. While newcomers can easily follow the narrative, some players find the post-main story exploration limited due to the lack of open-world mechanics, leading to mixed feelings about the overall storytelling experience.
“I love the first one; I'm so happy he's back, and we get more into the story to find Tim's dad.”
“However, it features lots of great Pokémon from Hoenn, Kalos, and Galar, to name a few, and an interesting storyline.”
“I haven't played the first Detective Pikachu game, but if you've watched the film, it's easy to pick up the storyline.”
“Only criticism I'd make is it's not that easy once you've completed the main story arc to go back and visit all the areas - as there aren't any significant wide-open-world mechanics (not like Arceus or Pokémon Scarlet/Violet) - nonetheless you can go back and replay individual levels from a selection menu.”
“Lame story”
graphics
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
25%
75%
The graphics have received mixed reviews, with some players appreciating the nostalgic charm reminiscent of old-school graphic adventure games, while others criticize them as rough and subpar compared to modern titles. Despite the attractive and adorable designs noted by some, the overall visual quality has been described as lacking, contributing to a mechanically dull experience.
“Attractive and adorable graphics, along with good quality sound and voices, make meeting new Pokémon quite fun. It's neat to control different Pokémon.”
“It's quite reminiscent of old-school graphic adventure games as opposed to modern Pokémon games.”
“Bosses consist of mashing the button 'A', and the graphics are terrible.”
“Mechanically boring, so much backtracking, rough-looking graphics.”
gameplay
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
25%
75%
The gameplay of Detective Pikachu Returns is characterized by straightforward investigation mechanics that some players find simplistic and frustrating, particularly due to limited exploration options and a lack of variety. While players can replay individual levels, the absence of expansive open-world elements and the need for backtracking detract from the overall experience, making it feel more suited for a younger audience.
“Detective Pikachu Returns is more adventures with the charming electric mouse from the original, but the straightforward investigation mechanics can be incredibly engaging and enjoyable for fans of the genre.”
“Only criticism I'd make is it's not that easy once you've completed the main story arc to go back and visit all the areas, as there aren't any significant wide-open-world mechanics (not like Arceus or Pokémon Scarlet/Violet). Nonetheless, you can go back and replay individual levels from a selection menu.”
“Too simplistic for anyone other than a youngster; investigation areas are small, and there's not enough gameplay variety.”
“Detective Pikachu Returns is more adventures with the charming electric mouse from the original, but the straightforward investigation mechanics can be incredibly frustrating in a game that wouldn't look out of place on the Wii U.”
humor
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
200%
The humor in the game is characterized by its gentle and charming approach, particularly through well-crafted cutscenes and writing that highlight the quirky personality of Detective Pikachu. This makes it an engaging experience for younger players, blending adventure and mystery with lighthearted moments.
“The cutscenes and writing have moments of humor and charm, especially revolving around its star, Detective Pikachu.”
“This game serves as a well-made, gentle adventure and mystery primer for younger players, filled with delightful humor.”