Burden of Proof
- July 26, 2018
- RobProductions
In "Burden of Proof," players become lawyers who must argue cases and present evidence in a courtroom setting. The game features a variety of cases to solve, requiring strategic thinking and quick responses during cross-examinations. With its unique premise and emphasis on critical thinking, Burden of Proof offers a fresh take on the courtroom drama genre.
Reviews
- Burden of Proof is a charming homage to the Ace Attorney series, featuring engaging characters and a well-written story that keeps players invested.
- The game offers a unique blend of courtroom drama and 3D exploration, allowing players to investigate crime scenes in a more immersive way.
- Despite its rough graphics, the game showcases a lot of heart and creativity, especially considering it was developed by a small team or even a solo developer.
- The graphics are often criticized for being bland and lifeless, with character designs that lack inspiration and polish.
- Some players found the writing to be inconsistent, with certain characters and plot points feeling underdeveloped or poorly executed.
- The game suffers from pacing issues and a lack of immersion due to clashing comedic and serious tones, which can detract from the overall experience.
- story70 mentions
- 37 % positive mentions
- 57 % neutral mentions
- 6 % negative mentions
The game's story is praised for being thought-provoking and enjoyable, with well-written cases and a coherent main plot, despite some flaws in pacing and logic. While it features unique storylines and memorable characters, some reviews note issues with writing quality and absurd plot elements. Overall, the narrative is engaging and offers a rich experience, particularly for fans of the genre, with a steady pace that keeps players invested throughout.
“The story was great and I liked how all of the cases were connected and had a common theme throughout the storyline.”
“The characters are interesting and well-defined, the plot is clever and carefully planned, and the storytelling is engaging.”
“So much devotion has gone into every aspect of 'Burden of Proof' that I can say this is a real game, with 10+ hours of multi-mystery that deserves to be played and shared by those who love a good story.”
“This game is obviously a fan-made game, so graphics and sound aside, the writing was poor and full of holes. The logic was not logical, and many drastic elements of the plot are dropped casually and never really explored or fully explained.”
“Instead of other big-name company productions where they manage to strike a good balance of drama and humor, this game fails at that aspect. While sure, the game can provide a chuckle and engross you in its story, it rarely manages to combine both for great effect.”
“Ridiculous leaps of logic, absurd storyline, and idiotic characters.”
- graphics32 mentions
- 19 % positive mentions
- 69 % neutral mentions
- 13 % negative mentions
The graphics of the game are generally described as simple and nostalgic, with a charming art style that may not impress in terms of realism or detail. While some players appreciate the unique textures and quirky character designs, many agree that the graphics are not the game's strong point and should not overshadow its storytelling and gameplay. Overall, the visuals are seen as adequate for the game's intent, though there is a desire for improvement in realism and environmental detail.
“There's something really charming about this game; the graphics are simple and adorably nostalgic, the characters have little funny and/or cute quirks about them, and the game is self-aware. I really enjoy finding the little hidden dialogues and easter eggs sprinkled throughout.”
“The graphics are obviously not the most awesome ones to find, yet they developed a certain sense of fascination in me for this style since some textures were well applied.”
“The exploration involves 3D movement, which I found very enjoyable, and I believe it justifies the use of 3D visuals even if they overall are required to be simpler than hyper-realistic AAA models that can be found in high production games.”
“This game is obviously a fan-made game, so graphics and sound aside, the writing was poor and full of holes. The logic was not logical, and many drastic elements of the plot are dropped casually and never really explored or fully explained.”
“My first issue with the game is the graphics.”
“While I understand that this is a 3D game and that can and indeed does take a lot of work and time to make, I still feel as though more work should have been done to make the graphics more realistic with regard to proportions of the characters.”
- gameplay32 mentions
- 19 % positive mentions
- 72 % neutral mentions
- 9 % negative mentions
The gameplay is generally well-received, drawing strong comparisons to the Ace Attorney series, with responsive mechanics and a blend of adventure and crime scene investigation elements. While some players feel it lacks innovation and could benefit from additional puzzle mechanics, the overall experience is smooth and engaging for fans of the genre. Despite minor criticisms, the gameplay effectively supports the narrative and character development, making it enjoyable for those who prioritize story over graphics.
“The gameplay and style are similar to those in Ace Attorney, so that fans can be delighted should they enjoy such elements.”
“A few new mechanics and changes make the overall experience much smoother and less frustrating, while also piquing interest in the player.”
“Rob Productions tells a small yet depth-filling blockbuster of a tale and combines it with adventure and crime scene investigation gameplay that dives into what it means to be a lawyer in another universe.”
“But gameplay only works if the rest of the game works, which, for me, doesn’t.”
“This game didn't try to create something new by improving upon the original game mechanics from the original AA series.”
“It functions very similar to the AA series with a couple of minor differences in investigation and courtroom mechanics which are not better or worse than AA, in my opinion, just different.”
- music20 mentions
- 40 % positive mentions
- 45 % neutral mentions
- 15 % negative mentions
The music in the game is praised for its charm and ability to enhance the emotional weight of scenes, reminiscent of the Ace Attorney series. Players appreciate the distinct tracks assigned to characters, which enrich their personalities, and the overall soundtrack is noted for its variety, blending hip-hop influences with dramatic and cheerful tones that effectively set the game's atmosphere. While some tracks may not be memorable, they contribute positively to the storytelling and character development.
“The soundtrack is really good; I was surprised by how much I liked quite a few of the tunes, especially in the courtroom!”
“The music is very hip hop beat-themed; it can get slow, can get dramatic, but seems to take inspiration from the Ace Attorney titles.”
“The music seems to fit the surroundings, sometimes gritty, sometimes cheerful, sometimes dramatic and urgent.”
“Furthermore, one of my favorite parts of the game is that certain characters receive a distinct music track which enhances the aura that they project.”
- humor14 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The game's humor is characterized by charming, quirky characters and self-aware writing, with hidden dialogues and easter eggs that add to its appeal. While it can elicit chuckles and has a nostalgic charm, it struggles to effectively balance humor with drama, often relying on repetitive jokes that lose their impact. Overall, the humor is likened to other indie titles, featuring memorable characters and witty moments that feel natural rather than forced.
“There's something really charming about this game; the graphics are simple and adorably nostalgic, the characters have little funny and/or cute quirks about them, and the game is self-aware. I really enjoy finding the little hidden dialogues and easter eggs sprinkled throughout.”
“The characters are memorable with a dash of witty humor that never feels forced.”
“The humor, quirkiness, and writing style is very much like AA, and you can find similarities almost immediately.”
- emotional2 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The emotional aspect of the game is highlighted as both touching and tragic, showcasing the author's strong writing skills that effectively evoke deep feelings in players.
“It is touching and tragic, and the author can clearly write.”