Skip to main content

Games like Maybe I Shouldn't Have Gone Down the Rabbit Hole After All

Looking for games like Maybe I Shouldn't Have Gone Down the Rabbit Hole After All? Here are top platformer recommendations, selected from player-similarity data — start with The Protagonist, Benign Land or Clicky & Yo.

Change display type

Skip Platform filter

Skip Play Mode filter

Skip Price filter
  • 58%Game Brain Score
    story, atmosphere
    graphics
    93% User Score Based on 14 reviews

    The Protagonist is a narrative-driven psychological horror game set 635 years after the sun died. You play as Varon, a man searching the underground ruins of humanity for his missing daughter.

    View Game
    View Game
  • 67%Game Brain Score
    graphics, atmosphere
    story, gameplay
    82% User Score Based on 33 reviews

    Benign Land is a surreal walking simulator that explores Ireland's layered past through 17 evocative scenes, blending mythology, history, and collective memory. Players journey from ancient pagan sites to the Irish Famine and the Troubles, experiencing a cryptic, symbolic narrative. It offers a unique, immersive artistic experience unlike traditional games.

    View Game
    View Game
  • At the heart of Clicky & Yo lies a psychological horror narrative experience that unfolds as a first-person enigma, where reality begins to fracture with every step you take toward understanding. At first, everything seems calm—a familiar environment you recognize and comprehend. Yet as you move forward, that same world slowly transforms into something unstable, unsettling, and deeply personal…

    View Game
    View Game
  • A psychological horror game that blurs the lines between love, fear, and reality. The story begins with Eve Levine, a college student caught in a nightmare after being abducted on a rainy evening in the shadowy St. Peters Park. Her fiancé, Adam Hale, a poet haunted by his own creations, must confront the darkness that emerges from his mysterious writings.

    View Game
    View Game
  • Whispers in the Fog is a first-person, psychological horror experience focused on atmosphere, exploration, and unraveling a deeply personal mystery. You awaken in a foggy rainy forest, your memory is a blank slate, armed with nothing but a flashlight. The thick, eerie woods pulse with haunting whispers. Shadowy figures dart through the mist at unnatural speeds, amplifying the dread of being utter…

    View Game
    View Game
  • 53%Game Brain Score
    atmosphere, gameplay
    90% User Score Based on 10 reviews

    I found myself in a strange house and I'm scared. I think I got into some kind of loop. The house is constantly changing, surely I saw something inexplicable and terrible. I have to get out of here. Every time I go through a cycle, one of the chains on the basement door disappears. I should probably get in there and get out of here. I'm very scared.

    View Game
    View Game
  • After losing his daughter, a broken detective clings to the sound of her voice — until an accident pulls him into a twisted nightmare. Trapped in haunting echoes of her past, he must solve puzzles and uncover chilling clues to stop a deranged man from sacrificing his child... to bring back his own.

    View Game
    View Game
  • Four friends gather under cloudy skies in a forgotten graveyard, united by a shared past and the memory of a man who vanished from their lives a decade ago. His name was Avoir Cafard. All he left behind was a Blue Book, filled with fragments of his past. Avoir lived in the decaying Soviet port city of Tishgorod, a place where sorrow clung to the air and life moved in a slow, unrelenting rhythm…

    View Game
    View Game
  • AN EMOTIONAL AND DREAMLIKE ADVENTURE Follow My Steps is a narrative open world RPG blending exploration, stealth, magical combat, and impactful moral choices. Play as Sova, protect and raise Lou, your wolf pup. Together, forge a unique bond that will shape your journey and lead to one of its many endings. Sova is neither a chosen one nor a warrior. She is a mother. And her world is falling apart.…

    View Game
    View Game
  • 63%Game Brain Score
    music, atmosphere
    story, graphics
    82% User Score Based on 28 reviews

    In "The Silent Swan" , players assume the role of Mirov, who awakens 17 years in the future and enters a mysterious land to uncover the truth about his past. This first-person narrative experience features open levels and walking simulator mechanics, with exploration taking place across sprawling urban areas connected by landbridges. Uncover the tale of two cities, Urzhum and Sernur, and the intertwining fates of Mirov and Selene in this intriguing title.

    View Game
    View Game