Metaphor: ReFantazio

The graphics of the game have received mixed reviews, with many praising its unique and stunning art style that evokes a strong aesthetic appeal, reminiscent of the Persona series. However, several players noted that the technical aspects, such as graphical fidelity and performance, feel outdated, often likening them to PS3-era visuals. Overall, while the art direction is celebrated, the lack of modern graphical enhancements and optimization issues have left some players disappointed.

The grinding aspect of the game has received mixed feedback, with some players appreciating the streamlined and innovative systems that make grinding feel less tedious, while others find it still requires significant time investment, especially on higher difficulties. Many reviewers noted that the real-time combat allows for quicker grinding, but the need to optimize archetypes and manage resources can lead to frustration and repetitive gameplay. Overall, while grinding is a core element of the experience, its execution varies, with some players enjoying the challenge and others feeling it detracts from the overall enjoyment of the game.

Overall, the game's optimization has received mixed reviews, with some players experiencing significant performance issues, particularly on lower-end systems and the Steam Deck, while others report smooth gameplay on high-end rigs. Many users noted that despite initial optimization patches, performance can degrade in later stages of the game, and some technical problems persist, such as frame drops and texture pop-ins. While the game is praised for its visuals and gameplay, the consensus is that further optimization is needed to enhance the experience for all players.

The emotional aspect of the game has garnered mixed but generally positive feedback, with many players expressing that it successfully evokes a range of feelings, from laughter to tears. While some moments are described as deeply moving and impactful, particularly in character arcs and story reveals, others feel that it doesn't quite reach the emotional heights of previous titles in the Persona series. Overall, players appreciate the heartfelt storytelling and character development, though some critique the pacing and certain plot points that detract from the emotional experience.

Character development in the game receives mixed reviews, with some praising its depth and emotional impact, particularly through the introduction of a voiced protagonist and well-crafted character arcs. However, many critics feel it falls short compared to previous titles in the Persona series, citing a lack of depth and meaningful interactions, especially for side characters. Overall, while character designs are generally well-received, the development aspect is seen as inconsistent, with some players finding it engaging and others deeming it lackluster.

The humor in the game is a mixed bag, featuring genuinely funny moments and clever banter among the cast, which often contrasts with the darker themes present in the story. While some players appreciate the quirky characters and comedic situations, others feel that the humor could be more prevalent, especially in social interactions. Overall, the game successfully balances humor with serious undertones, providing a range of emotional experiences for players.

The atmosphere of the game is widely praised for its immersive world-building, enhanced by a hauntingly beautiful soundtrack that complements the emotional depth of each scene. Players appreciate the vibrant art direction and the way music elevates gameplay, although some note that certain cutscenes lack the same atmospheric impact. Overall, the combination of music, narration, and detailed environments creates a captivating experience that draws players into the game's fantasy world.

Overall, the game's stability is generally praised, with many users reporting smooth performance across various platforms, including Steam Deck and high-end PCs, with minimal crashes or stuttering. However, some players have encountered specific bugs, particularly related to achievements not unlocking, and occasional frame rate drops in certain areas. Despite these issues, the majority of players find the game runs well and is enjoyable.

Overall, the game is criticized for its limited replayability due to a linear story with few diverging paths and the ability to fully customize the job system in a single playthrough. Players feel that the lack of meaningful choices and new game+ content diminishes the incentive to replay, leaving them with little motivation to return after completing the game.

The monetization strategy of the game has been criticized for feeling like a cash grab, leveraging the goodwill of the Persona series while offering minimal additional content through DLCs. Despite the absence of overt advertisements, the game is perceived as unfinished and reflective of a company known for its predatory practices and recycling of material.