Melvor Idle - Idle RPG
Get on Play StoreMelvor Idle - Idle RPG is a browser-based game that combines the mechanics of idle/incremental games with the immersive world and lore of a traditional RPG, inspired by RuneScape. The game boasts impressive graphics and intricate gameplay, but may be overly grindy and marred by bugs and intrusive ads for some players. Despite these flaws, Melvor Idle offers a unique and engaging experience for fans of the genre.
Phone
Android
Mobile Platform
Tablet
Reviews
- Great idle game that captures the essence of Runescape without the tediousness of walking around.
- No intrusive ads and a fair one-time purchase model make this game enjoyable.
- The game offers a lot of content and depth, making it engaging for both casual and dedicated players.
- The game has significant performance issues, including lag and crashes, especially on mobile devices.
- Many skills and features are locked behind a paywall, which frustrates players who enjoyed the free version.
- The user interface is clunky and not intuitive, making navigation difficult for new players.
- monetization105 mentions
- 21 % positive mentions
- 13 % neutral mentions
- 66 % negative mentions
The monetization model of the game is largely praised for its lack of intrusive ads and microtransactions, with many users appreciating the one-time purchase option for the full version that unlocks additional content. While some players report minor issues with banner ads affecting gameplay, the consensus is that the game offers a fair and enjoyable experience without the typical pay-to-win mechanics found in many other titles. Overall, players value the absence of aggressive monetization tactics, making it a standout in the idle game genre.
“There are no ads and the only monetization is to upgrade to the full version, which simply opens more skills to train.”
“This game has absolutely zero microtransactions, and is an incredibly satisfying time-sink.”
“Great indie game, free to play with no in-app purchases, only to buy pro (a one-time small payment) to support a one-developer game.”
“There's literally nothing to this game other than its homage to RuneScape; it's all text with a few simple images. Definitely not worth what they are asking for to unlock the full version. It smells like a quick cash grab, especially after seeing skills like prayer were locked behind a paywall. It was an easy uninstall; surely, there's a better way to monetize rather than locking normally free skills.”
“Game is now pay to play with a lot of ads.”
“Can't even start the game because ads move the entire game over, blocking all interactions, with no way to clear.”
- gameplay65 mentions
- 45 % positive mentions
- 51 % neutral mentions
- 5 % negative mentions
The gameplay is generally praised for its engaging idle mechanics and diverse skill progression, reminiscent of classic RPGs like RuneScape, allowing for both active and offline play. However, some users note issues with a convoluted UI, slow pacing, and occasional lag, which can detract from the overall experience. Despite these drawbacks, many appreciate the lack of intrusive ads and microtransactions, highlighting the developer's commitment to improving the game based on player feedback.
“But the gameplay and skill progression in this game has kept me very engaged, and that's just the free version!”
“The gameplay is solid and you can tell there is a lot of love put into the game but it does need a little work.”
“Brilliant game, it's refreshing to have a game that you can play on mobile that's not pay to win and that offers this many hours of gameplay, if you are into RuneScape at all then this game is definitely worth playing.”
“Thank you :) a recent update to the game (around another rework of their township mechanic) has made it largely unplayable.”
“The UI is confusing, and the gameplay is shallow.”
“Gameplay can be very laggy when switching between screens and purchasing/selling items.”
- grinding61 mentions
- 5 % positive mentions
- -3 % neutral mentions
- 98 % negative mentions
Overall, players appreciate the game's ability to capture the essence of grinding found in traditional RPGs like RuneScape, while minimizing the tediousness typically associated with it. Many enjoy the idle mechanics that allow for skill progression without constant active engagement, though some express a desire for improvements in user interface and farming mechanics. While the game is described as "grindy," it is often seen as a more casual and accessible alternative to more demanding MMORPGs.
“This game is amazing! The grinding aspect keeps me engaged and motivated to level up.”
“I love the grind in this game; it feels rewarding and satisfying to see my progress.”
“The grinding mechanics are well-balanced, making it enjoyable to farm for resources.”
“It somewhat quickly turns from an active incremental/leveling game to one of the slowest AFK farming games there are.”
“The entire game is centered around leveling up your character's skills and farming better gear, but there's nothing remotely close to representing a satisfying payoff.”
“You just grind skills, and then you hit the attack/defense requirements for items you crafted, which can only be met by grinding the dull and tedious combat - the only part of the game which is not 'idle' - you literally sit there for hours leveling battle skills.”
- optimization58 mentions
- 24 % positive mentions
- 52 % neutral mentions
- 24 % negative mentions
The game suffers from significant optimization issues, particularly on mobile devices, leading to lag, crashes, and unresponsive menus. While the gameplay is enjoyable, many users report that performance has deteriorated with recent updates, making it nearly unplayable on certain phones. In contrast, the PC version runs smoothly, highlighting the need for dedicated optimization efforts for mobile platforms.
“With a bit more optimization, this game will be perfect.”
“This is an excellent idle game but the performance is really poor on mobile and needs to be optimized.”
“The actual gameplay itself is fun, but the optimization is terrible.”
“However, it seems to need a lot of optimizations behind the scenes, because it is very laggy, whether opening a menu, clicking a button, or trying to buy/sell something.”
“I wish I had discovered the game earlier, but it's unplayable; absurdly unoptimized, each update slows the game even more to the point I could barely select anything I wanted to do by the time I uninstalled.”
“Absolutely horrible performance; the game lags for about 5 seconds every time you do an action.”
- graphics39 mentions
- 18 % positive mentions
- 74 % neutral mentions
- 8 % negative mentions
The graphics of the game are generally described as simple, minimalistic, and reminiscent of old-school titles like RuneScape, with many users noting that the visuals are not a priority. While some appreciate the sleek and distinct art style, others report issues such as lag and performance problems despite the lack of complex graphics. Overall, players seem to agree that while the graphics could use improvement, the gameplay experience remains enjoyable for those who prioritize mechanics over visuals.
“Visuals: simple, distinct and sleek.”
“Text and icon based with great UI and artwork.”
“Great idle game, got a Runescape feel to it, reminds me a lot of it without the graphics, must play if you dig old school vibes.”
“The graphics are a little subpar, even for a RuneScape-themed game.”
“For a game with such simple graphics, it freezes and gets stuck too much.”
“Extremely laggy for no graphics, with loading screens between pages.”
- stability34 mentions
- 9 % positive mentions
- -3 % neutral mentions
- 94 % negative mentions
The game's stability has been widely criticized, with numerous users reporting frequent freezes, crashes, and lag, particularly on mobile devices. Many players express frustration over the game's performance, especially after recent updates, which have exacerbated these issues. While some users have experienced smooth gameplay, the overwhelming consensus is that the game is currently plagued by significant stability problems, rendering it nearly unplayable for many.
“The game is bug-free and runs smoothly.”
“I appreciate the stability of the game; it enhances the overall experience.”
“The performance is consistent, making for a seamless gaming experience.”
“Constantly freezes for seconds at a time as it seems to be trying to load in assets.”
“What's normally a 5-star game is currently 0 stars and is a miserable experience for me. I updated the game, bought the DLC, and since then everything is laggy and freezes. Currently not worth playing, which is extremely disappointing!”
“The game freezes and/or crashes nearly constantly for me.”
- story8 mentions
- 25 % positive mentions
- 38 % neutral mentions
- 38 % negative mentions
The game's story aspect is largely criticized for its lack of engaging quests and narrative depth, leaving players feeling that the experience is more about grinding than meaningful progression. Users express a desire for a quest system to enhance gameplay and provide a more immersive experience, as the current setup feels simplistic and poorly optimized. Overall, the absence of a compelling story detracts from the enjoyment of the game.
“Instead of just running everything for you, you have missions and progression and have to watch what you're doing.”
“I just hope they add a quest system one day!!”
“I just hope they add a quest system one day!”
“I love this, and I'm just wondering if you plan on providing quests and questlines so it doesn't feel like grinding levels, and more like a game.”
“Trying to complete a quest but there's no way to do it.”
- music7 mentions
- 29 % positive mentions
- 29 % neutral mentions
- 43 % negative mentions
The reviews consistently express disappointment over the absence of music and sound in the game, with many users stating that the addition of background music would significantly enhance their gaming experience and prolong their playtime. Despite enjoying the game overall, the lack of audio elements is a common critique that detracts from its appeal.
“Great game, but it needs sound, music, something.”
“Love this game; it's so much less draining, hahaha, but for Christ's sake, please add some sounds, music, or something.”
“No music or sound.”
“Would be much better if it had music.”
“I don't like how there's not any background music; if there was background music, I would play a lot longer.”
- emotional2 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
Users appreciate the emotional depth of the game, highlighting its wholesome nature and the sense of genuine care behind its creation, contrasting it with corporate-driven titles. However, some express frustration over technical issues, such as lost progress, which detracted from their overall experience.
“And it feels wholesome, a labor of love and not a corporate microtransaction cash grab.”
- humor1 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
Players find the humor in the game's demo, noting its extensive content makes it amusingly misleading to label it as just a demo.
“I'm playing the demo currently, which has such a large amount of content, it's hilarious to call it a demo.”
