Idle Magic School
Get on Play StoreCome join us to build and manage your own magic school!
Phone
Android
Mobile Platform
Tablet
Reviews
- Cute graphics and engaging gameplay.
- Optional ads that provide rewards without being intrusive.
- Fun idle game with a magical school theme.
- Game crashes frequently, especially after updates.
- No cloud save feature, leading to loss of progress.
- Limited content with only a few schools available, making it repetitive.
- monetization1,294 mentions
- 16 % positive mentions
- 2 % neutral mentions
- 82 % negative mentions
The monetization aspect of the game has received mixed reviews, with many players noting the prevalence of ads that are often necessary for progression. While some appreciate the option to watch ads for rewards, others find the frequency of ads excessive and feel that purchasing the "no ads" option, which ranges from $10 to $20, is essential for a more enjoyable experience. However, there are complaints about technical issues related to in-app purchases, such as losing access to the no ads feature after reinstalling the game, leading to frustration among players who have invested money. Overall, while the game offers optional ads that can enhance gameplay, many users feel that the reliance on ads for progression detracts from the overall experience.
“I bought the no ads upgrade previously and when I try to buy it again, it errors out saying I already own it.”
“The no-ads upgrade is worth the price I think; it feels like a fair price to buy a game and not be annoyed by ads or pay-to-win.”
“I love this game, I also paid for the no ads option and the 10-hour offline upgrade too, which makes the fact that I completed the game in 3 days a bit disappointing.”
“I paid $10 to disable ads and wish I hadn't; the third school is a tedious slog with upgrades costing quintillions while your income is still in the hundred trillions.”
“I paid to remove the ads and it was money well spent, but now the game is unplayable because the ads keep crashing it.”
“You will spend more time watching ads than playing, unless you pay the $15 fee to remove them.”
- graphics176 mentions
- 69 % positive mentions
- 30 % neutral mentions
- 2 % negative mentions
The graphics of the game are widely praised for their cuteness, quality, and attention to detail, contributing to an enjoyable visual experience. Many users appreciate the charming art style and smooth animations, which enhance the overall gameplay. However, some players have noted occasional graphical issues and a desire for improved resolution or customization options.
“The graphics are fantastic.”
“The graphics are well done and have such cute details.”
“Beautifully detailed graphics, runs along at a nice pace.”
“I also keep getting randomly pulled into the water part of the map, which freezes the game and creates a graphical error.”
“Just the graphics can be improved much more for better resolution.”
“What brings it down, apart from the amateurish graphics, is that it very shamelessly rips off Harry Potter without trying to hide it, but does it very half-assed.”
- gameplay130 mentions
- 41 % positive mentions
- 57 % neutral mentions
- 2 % negative mentions
The gameplay is generally praised for its enjoyable mechanics, cute graphics, and addictive nature, though many players express frustration with the heavy reliance on ads, which can disrupt the experience and limit progression. While the game offers a fun loop and balanced management systems, some users report a lack of content and repetitive gameplay as they reach later stages, leading to diminished engagement. Overall, players appreciate the game's charm but desire more varied mechanics and content updates to sustain long-term interest.
“The gameplay is fun, but once you get to a certain point the game stops providing you with coins when you complete tasks, and starts giving you ads every 10 seconds.”
“Smooth gameplay and fun art style.”
“Great gameplay and I love the game itself but the only problem is when loading in it takes ages or kicks me out of the game by disconnecting or crashing itself.”
“The newest stage is the smallest yet, adds no new room types or mechanics.”
“There's not much to do when you reach late game (4th school), due to the cost of upgrades; the gameplay drops off hard.”
“The game itself can be fun, but it is very simple and at the same time the gameplay is significantly gimped by the ads.”
- stability117 mentions
- 3 % positive mentions
- 2 % neutral mentions
- 96 % negative mentions
The game's stability is a significant issue, with numerous users reporting frequent freezes and crashes, particularly during loading screens and when attempting to upgrade certain features like the canteen. Many players express frustration over being unable to progress due to these bugs, with some even resorting to force-closing the app to regain control. While a few users have experienced smooth gameplay, the overwhelming consensus is that the game is currently plagued by stability problems that detract from the overall experience.
“Runs great on my older Android phone.”
“Smooth graphics, no glitches, and very easy to understand.”
“Game runs great and is quite well balanced.”
“However, it freezes and crashes constantly to an annoying level randomly every few minutes from tapping.”
“I was enjoying it to begin with, but now every time I click on the cafeteria, the game freezes and crashes.”
“Every time I try to load the game, it freezes on the loading screen and crashes.”
- story75 mentions
- 33 % positive mentions
- 61 % neutral mentions
- 5 % negative mentions
The game's story is generally well-received, with players appreciating its engaging narrative and charming characters. However, many users express frustration over the lack of quests and missions in the later stages, particularly in the third school, which diminishes the sense of progression and exploration. Overall, while the storyline has potential, players desire more content and variety to enhance their experience.
“Building your own magic school and then opening its branches, and the best part of this game is that it has a good story.”
“The characters are so adorable and I really enjoy the concept and its story.”
“Adorable, fun, entertaining, and most of all, this tycoon has an actual storyline!”
“I just don't like games that only make you follow missions.”
“The third school looks nice but... holy water didn't get expanded so now I'm accumulating more and more useless holy water, the missions/objectives have been removed for some reason, leaving little sense of progression.”
“I left a review already, but I forgot to add the fact that I also don't understand why there are no longer quests or whatever they were called to complete?”
- grinding44 mentions
- 7 % positive mentions
- -5 % neutral mentions
- 98 % negative mentions
The reviews indicate that the game features significant grinding, especially in later levels, where players often find progress slow and tedious, requiring extensive waiting for resources to accumulate. While some players enjoy the grinding aspect and find it rewarding, many express frustration with the imbalance in upgrade costs versus income, leading to a repetitive experience. Overall, the game is seen as fun initially, but it becomes increasingly grindy and may deter those who dislike prolonged grinding sessions.
“The grinding in this game strikes a perfect balance; it feels rewarding without being tedious.”
“I appreciate how the grind is designed to be engaging, making each level-up feel like a real achievement.”
“The grind is satisfying and offers a sense of progression that keeps me coming back for more.”
“I paid $10 to disable ads and wish I hadn't; the third school is a tedious slog with upgrades costing quintillions while your income is still in the hundred trillions.”
“Months of grinding have led to no new content.”
“However, the game is very, very grindy, sometimes requiring hundreds of thousands of gold to upgrade a single thing.”
- music37 mentions
- 41 % positive mentions
- 51 % neutral mentions
- 8 % negative mentions
The music in the game is generally praised for its beauty, variety, and ability to enhance the gaming experience, with specific highlights on the relaxing themes and upbeat tracks associated with different areas. However, some users have noted issues with repetitive tunes during extended play and technical problems that cause the music to continue playing even after exiting the app. Overall, the soundtrack is considered a strong aspect of the game, contributing to its enjoyable atmosphere.
“I especially like the music for the water college, which I end up leaving the game on to listen while studying.”
“The music is great as it is different per area, a nice touch.”
“Love the music and vibes from this game.”
“Just one thing, the music is pretty lame.”
“Also try to add some theme world soundtrack that reflects magic a bit more.”
“It launches, plays about 7 seconds of music and then crashes :(”
- humor22 mentions
- 95 % positive mentions
- -9 % neutral mentions
- 14 % negative mentions
The humor in the game is largely derived from its playful references and parodies of popular culture, particularly the Harry Potter series, which many players find hilarious and entertaining. While some appreciate the clever twists and comedic elements, others criticize aspects like monetization, suggesting that the humor can sometimes overshadow gameplay concerns. Overall, the game is generally regarded as funny, with a mix of amusing dialogues and lighthearted concepts that enhance the experience.
“Nice and funny references to other games or movies.”
“It's based off of Harry Potter, so it's funny to see how they've changed things to avoid copyright.”
“But it's funny as you would expect a Potter parody lol.”
“It's not funny.”
“The jokes fall flat and feel forced.”
“I expected more humor, but it just didn't land.”
- optimization8 mentions
- 38 % positive mentions
- 25 % neutral mentions
- 38 % negative mentions
Overall, while the game is enjoyable and engaging, players have noted significant optimization issues, particularly with the magic tower and the last two maps, which detract from the experience. The grindiness of certain elements, such as leveling up in specific schools, also highlights the need for better resource management and optimization. Additionally, the lack of cross-device progress sharing is seen as a missed opportunity for enhancing gameplay, especially for idle game enthusiasts.
“Decent idle game, good balancing to keep players engaged, but lacking a feature to share progress between devices, which I think is quite fundamental for an idle game since it's better run on a simulator when one has access to computers, for both performance, connection, and battery.”
“Also, winter land and sky city should be optimized.”
“This app is a really fun game. I like the performance of it where humans can become wizards. It's still a really fun app and I recommend it to anyone.”
“The game is entertaining, but in some areas it is not optimized properly.”
“The magic tower is badly optimized in terms of gold, and it doesn't feel worth doing raids for gold because the amount gained is always so minimal.”
“The last two maps are really unoptimized, though.”
- replayability6 mentions
- 33 % positive mentions
- 17 % neutral mentions
- 50 % negative mentions
The game's replayability is largely criticized due to inadequate saving features and a lack of content, with players noting that only three out of five advertised levels are accessible. Many feel that once the initial levels are completed, there is little incentive to return until new updates are released, and the absence of a reset mechanic further diminishes replay value. While some find the gameplay relaxing, the overall sentiment is that the game currently lacks sufficient replayability.
“It is relaxing for me; earning runes is easy, so there's no need to actually buy at this moment, which makes it more playable.”
“Most idle games I have played have some form of 'reset' that provides bonuses for replays, but that isn't the case here, so the game's ability to keep replayability and interest is currently entirely dependent on new maps being released.”
“I would say to developers that the game lacks replay value, and once you've finished Sky School, there becomes no reason to open the game up until the next update.”
“Most idle games I have played have some form of 'reset' that provides bonuses for replays, but that isn't the case here, so the game's ability to maintain replayability and interest is currently entirely dependent on new maps being released.”
“Fun game if you pay for an adless experience ($5 on sale), however, it really needs to open the last school and come up with more schools; otherwise, it's very limited with zero replay value.”
- emotional6 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
Players find the game emotionally engaging, describing it as cozy and wholesome, evoking feelings of friendship and nostalgia reminiscent of the Harry Potter universe. Despite some technical issues, such as crashes, the overall sentiment is positive, with many expressing a deep affection for the game's charm and its ability to create a sense of connection.
“Such a cozy and wholesome game.”
“This game is the best game ever made; it made me feel like I was going to be a good friend to others.”
“It's a super cute and wholesome game!”
- character development2 mentions
- 0 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 100 % negative mentions
Character development in the game is heavily criticized for its lack of originality, as it relies on names, designs, and concepts directly lifted from the Harry Potter franchise, resulting in a derivative experience that fails to offer unique character growth or depth.
“The developer used both names and character designs from the Harry Potter franchise.”
“Otherwise, everything is shamelessly copied from Harry Potter, including character designs, item names, and spells.”
- atmosphere2 mentions
- 100 % positive mentions
- 0 % neutral mentions
- 0 % negative mentions
The atmosphere is highly praised, featuring engaging gameplay complemented by a captivating background music score and charming character art that enhances the overall experience.
“The atmosphere is great.”
“Very cool gameplay with nice atmospheric background music and cute iconic character art.”
