Freddi Fish 5 featuring Mess Hall Mania®: The Case of the Creature of Coral Cove

About

In "Freddi Fish 5: The Case of the Creature of Coral Cove," Freddi and Luther must investigate a mysterious sea creature that is scaring away all the visitors to Coral Cove. The duo will gather clues, solve puzzles, and interrogate suspects to uncover the truth behind the creature and save the struggling tourist season. Along the way, they'll meet new friends and learn about the importance of conservation and working together to protect the ocean environment.

Genres & Tags

Play Modes

Single-Player Play through the game's story or campaign solo

Freddi Fish 5 featuring Mess Hall Mania®: The Case of the Creature of Coral Cove screenshot

89%

Audience ScoreBased on 123 reviews

story4 positive mentions

character development2 negative mentions

The game is a nostalgic trip for many players, bringing back fond childhood memories and providing a fun experience for both kids and adults.
It features charming graphics, engaging characters, and a variety of puzzles that help develop critical thinking and problem-solving skills in children.
The voice acting and animation are well-executed, contributing to the overall enjoyment of the game.

Many players feel that this installment is the weakest in the Freddi Fish series, lacking the depth and complexity of earlier titles.
Some puzzles can be frustratingly difficult, and the game may feel slow-paced due to lengthy travel times and repetitive dialogue.
There are concerns about the game's accessibility and design choices, such as the lack of options for younger players or those with reading difficulties.

story
17 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
24%
59%
18%
The game's story revolves around an epic adventure to uncover the reasons behind a sea monster's terrorization of a park, featuring engaging character relationships and high-quality animation. However, while some players appreciate the interesting twists and character development, others criticize the dialogue and predictability of the plot, noting that it lacks the depth and creativity of earlier installments. Overall, the narrative is a mixed bag, with moments of charm overshadowed by cheesy elements and questionable character motivations.
- “In this game, instead of going on a mission to retrieve something that someone else stole, you go on a more epic adventure to discover why a sea monster is terrorizing a park.”
- “We got so attached to all of the characters, and invested in their heart-wrenching story.”
- “The story takes some slightly interesting twists and turns with its development, and I was left wondering what was going on.”
- “The jokes, the story, everything kinda falls flat on this one.”
- “This installment of Freddi Fish seems to have less thought put into the dialogue, puzzles, gameplay, and storyline than the games that came before it.”
- “The story does have a lot of cheesy and convenient moments.”
music
7 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
43%
14%
43%
The music in the game has received mixed reviews; while some players appreciate the soundtrack and find it engaging enough to linger in certain areas just to listen, others feel it lacks the catchy charm of previous installments. Additionally, certain tracks, like those in Coral Cove Park, have been described as unsettling. Overall, the music is considered a significant improvement, contributing positively to the game's aesthetic.
- “The voice acting, artwork, and music are all on point!”
- “However, the aesthetic design and music are probably at their best here, specifically the music being the biggest update.”
- “There's no songs like the second game, which were a cheesy hit like a Taco Bell taco or miss like your crappy jokes when no one wants to hear it.”
- “Loved this game, but I always thought some of the music in Coral Cove Park was kinda creepy.”
- “Seriously, I often find myself sitting in an area just to listen to the soundtrack.”
graphics
6 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
33%
33%
33%
The graphics are considered impressive for a game released in 2001, with many praising the overall aesthetic design, artwork, and music as standout features. While some feel the graphics surpass those of older titles, they still fall short of modern standards. Overall, the visual presentation is well-received, contributing positively to the game's appeal.
- “The voice acting, artwork, and music are all on point!”
- “The graphics, artwork, music, voice acting, plot, and more are all perfect; they are better than Freddi Fish 3!”
- “The graphics are pretty for a game released in 2001.”
- “The graphics were better than the older games but not good enough.”
humor
6 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The humor in the game is characterized by a blend of visual gags and character interactions, making it enjoyable for both children and adults. Players appreciate the clever storytelling and the comedic elements brought by characters like Marty and Xamfear, which continue to elicit laughter even years after initial play. Overall, the game is praised for its rich humor that enhances the overall experience.
- “I used to play this game when I was 7 and now I'm 22 and still laughing at the storytelling and the relationships that the characters share.”
- “But it's also still a fun, quick, and humorous game to click through as a grown-up.”
- “I find there's a lot more visual humor than verbal in this Freddi Fish game; a lot of the jokes are told through pictures and character actions rather than said out loud.”
gameplay
6 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
17%
33%
The gameplay is a blend of classic point-and-click adventure mechanics reminiscent of titles like Maniac Mansion and Monkey Island, featuring engaging activities for younger players. While some reviews note a decline in the quality of puzzles and dialogue compared to previous installments, the core gameplay remains enjoyable for both children and adults. Overall, it introduces new ideas while maintaining familiar elements, though opinions on character design vary.
- “Really interesting gameplay, but the main character, Freddi, is very ugly.”
- “As an adult, the gameplay still holds up and is still a fun point-and-click adventure game.”
- “This installment of Freddi Fish seems to have less thought put into the dialogue, puzzles, gameplay, and storyline than the games that came before it.”
- “Gameplay involves Maniac Mansion/Monkey Island style point-and-click adventuring combined with a few minigames and activities intended to keep young children occupied.”
character development
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Reviews indicate that character development in the game is lacking, with some users noting that it feels inferior to previous entries, despite changes in animation and character design. Overall, the narrative struggles to support meaningful growth for the characters.
- “The story was a bit off, but the character development was even worse.”
- “The animation and some character designs are different from previous entries.”
emotional
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Players find "Freddy Fish" to be an exceptionally wholesome experience, highlighting their deep attachment to the characters and the emotional weight of the story. The game's ability to evoke strong feelings and investment in its narrative is a standout feature.
- “We got so attached to all of the characters and invested in their heart-wrenching story.”
- “Games don't get more wholesome than Freddy Fish.”
stability
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The game has been criticized for being "too buggy," with numerous glitches that hinder gameplay, although it is noted to be less problematic than Freddi Fish 4. While the dialogue and writing are somewhat improved, there are still moments that leave players questioning character motivations and actions.
- “Eventually, our father looked at the game and concluded that it was 'too buggy' and couldn't be completed.”
- “The dialogue and writing aren't as atrocious as Freddi Fish 4 (and not as many weird glitches, to boot), but there are plenty of moments that made me raise my eyebrow and wonder why the characters in the story would do certain things.”
grinding
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
Players find the grinding aspect of the game can become tedious, particularly when it involves traveling to different areas of the map.
- “And sometimes moving to different parts of the map got tedious.”
- “The grinding feels endless and repetitive, making it hard to stay engaged.”
- “I found myself doing the same tasks over and over, which quickly became boring.”
replayability
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
The Freddi Fish games offer high replayability due to their multiple endings and a wealth of interactive elements, encouraging players to explore different outcomes and experiences.
- “The multiple endings and countless interactions significantly enhance the replayability of the Freddi Fish games.”
- “Each playthrough offers new surprises and challenges, making it hard to put down.”
- “The variety of choices and paths keeps the game fresh, encouraging players to dive back in for more.”