The core fishing mechanics are excellent and rewarding, providing a real challenge to catch larger fish.
The game features stunning graphics with detailed environments and realistic fish models, enhancing the immersive experience.
There is a vibrant user-based market for buying and selling equipment, which adds depth to the gameplay.
The game suffers from incomplete English translations, making it difficult for non-Russian speakers to understand mechanics and quests.
There is a lack of variety in gameplay beyond fishing, leading to a repetitive experience over time.
The absence of multiplayer options and the impending server shutdown limit the game's long-term appeal.
story
30 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
17%
70%
13%
The game's story and narrative elements are largely criticized for being underdeveloped and confusing, with players often feeling lost due to unclear quest objectives and poor navigation. While there are numerous quests and crafting opportunities, many players find the missions repetitive and frustrating, particularly for newcomers who struggle to progress. Overall, the lack of a cohesive and engaging storyline detracts from the gameplay experience, making it feel more like a grind than an adventure.
“Although missions, challenges, etc. offer valuable tiered components for rods themselves, such components could be found along rare catches anywhere across the map, with appropriate likelihood of said catches being attained.”
“The quests are good as well but they also do need some work because a lot are hard to do when you first start, but that can be worked on.”
“Has a quest line to follow and tons of stuff to buy and craft.”
“The game also lacks a story or narrative, which can make it feel repetitive after extended play sessions.”
“Created a character, logged in, picked up a quest (no indication of where to do it), all the locations are locked up, no other quests around, the quest board is equally as useless.”
“Some of the quests will leave you scratching your head so much on how to accomplish them that you will give up on them.”
gameplay
24 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
21%
54%
25%
The gameplay of the game is centered around solid fishing mechanics, offering various techniques and a dynamic environment that influences fish behavior. However, players criticize the lack of variety and depth beyond fishing, as well as insufficient instructions and clarity regarding mechanics, which can lead to confusion. While the core mechanics are well-executed, the overall experience is hampered by slow pacing and limited content, making it less appealing to some players.
“The game's mechanics are straightforward, with players using a fishing rod to catch fish.”
“The game also features a variety of fishing techniques, such as spinning and float fishing, which adds depth to the gameplay.”
“Different fish species are more active during certain times of the day or in certain weather conditions, adding a layer of strategy to the gameplay.”
“One of the downsides of Atom Fishing II is its lack of variety in gameplay.”
“While the fishing mechanics are well-implemented, there is not much else to do in the game besides catching fish.”
“Complete lack of info about mechanics, items, gear, shops, where to find/farm and what, and unless you are tipped off by someone from the game about the more specific fish - exact spots, depth, gear, time of day, bait - you will never catch one.”
graphics
9 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
33%
34%
33%
The graphics of Atom Fishing II receive mixed reviews, with some players praising them as impressive and well-designed, while others find them to be average or slightly dated. Overall, the game is noted for its decent optimization and stability, though performance may vary depending on the user's hardware.
“One of the most impressive aspects of Atom Fishing II is its graphics.”
“The game's graphics and level design are good, and the fishing mechanics are well-implemented.”
“So my advice would be to download and try it, the graphics are nice and the sound is good; it's only about a 1GB download as well and it runs pretty stable!”
“Graphics are ok but a bit dated.”
“Graphics are normal, optimization too.”
“This game was really slow and didn't have a tutorial; I don't recommend it. (The slowness might've been my graphics card.)”
grinding
6 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
83%
Players find the grinding aspect of the game to be excessive and unenjoyable, particularly in the early stages where they feel confined to a small area with repetitive quests. Many express frustration over the necessity of completing numerous tasks before being allowed to explore the broader game world, leading to a sense of monotony and dissatisfaction.
“You'll need a second life for grinding.”
“Grinding in this game is incredibly rewarding and keeps you engaged.”
“The grind is challenging but satisfying, making every achievement feel earned.”
“This grinding isn't fun.”
“It can get grindy.”
“I will never know if the outside world is any good or not because I'm not repeatedly grinding quests in a 10x10 playable box just to be able to open the door and step outside.”
atmosphere
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
75%
25%
The game's atmosphere is highly praised for its immersive environments and diverse locations, particularly appealing to fans of fishing and eco-simulations. The soundtrack enhances the overall experience, contributing to a vibrant and engaging setting that players find enjoyable.
“If you're into fishing and virtual eco-environment atmospheres coupled with sporting and recreational simulations, you will certainly enjoy this game.”
“Great soundtrack, locations, and atmosphere overall.”
“Great range of locations and atmospheric settings.”
music
4 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
50%
The music in the game receives mixed feedback; while some players appreciate the soundtrack and atmosphere, others find it obnoxious, though there is an option to mute it. Additionally, there are requests for more diverse music styles, such as post-apocalyptic Russian beats. Overall, the music contributes significantly to the game's ambiance.
“Love the music too - would like to hear more post-apocalyptic Russian fat beats added!”
“Great soundtrack, locations, and atmosphere overall.”
“Cannot turn the music off.”
“In-game music is obnoxious, but there is the option to mute it.”
humor
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
Users find the humor in the game to be genuinely funny, with some noting that the mix of pros and cons adds to the comedic experience of writing a review. Overall, the humor is appreciated and contributes positively to the game's appeal.
“There are so many pros and so many cons; it's hilarious to write a review.”
“Hahahaha, that's funny!”
“In spite of this meant-humorous entry, I digress.”
monetization
3 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
33%
100%
The monetization model features microtransactions, but players note that the game is free to play with optional in-game purchases, and there is no pressure to spend money.
“But if you look closely on the store page, it says 'in-app purchases'.”
“The worst part for me are the microtransactions.”
“If you look closely at the store page, it says 'in-app purchases'.”
“It's free with some in-game purchases, but there is no pressure to buy anything.”
optimization
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
50%
100%
The game's optimization is considered average, with some users noting that it requires improvement, particularly for newcomers. Despite these issues, players find the experience enjoyable and appreciate the supportive community.
“Best fishing slash survival MMO game out there. It needs optimization and can be hard in the beginning; however, the community is very helpful and it's fun to progress.”
“Graphics are normal; optimization is lacking.”
“Best fishing slash survival MMO game out there, but it needs optimization and can be hard in the beginning.”
stability
2 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
100%
The game's stability is severely criticized, with users reporting frequent freezes, buggy controls, and a lack of essential features like tutorials and key mapping, rendering it largely unplayable. Overall, players express significant frustration with the game's performance and functionality.
“No tutorial, no information; just spawn and do nothing. Animations are crap, buggy controls, and no key mapping. This is the worst game ever to exist—unplayable.”
“Game freezes after character description.”
replayability
1 mentions Positive Neutral Negative
300%
The game's replayability is somewhat limited due to the absence of online multiplayer or co-op modes, despite the inclusion of a tournament mode.
“While the game does include a tournament mode, there is no online multiplayer or co-op mode, which can limit the game's replayability.”
“After completing the main story, there isn't much incentive to play again, as the side quests feel repetitive and lack depth.”
“The lack of varied endings or choices means that once you've experienced the game, there's little reason to go back.”